Setting Out a Family from Clues
A family puzzle gives you five to eight people and a handful of clues in no helpful order: "In a family of six members, E, G, H, I, J and K, there are two married couples…" Each clue is easy on its own. The work is in holding them all together. So do not draw people in the order the clues arrive. Sort the clues first, in three passes.
Pass 1: generations
Look for the words that cross generations: grandfather, granddaughter, great-grandmother, and every father, mother, son or daughter. Decide how many generations there are and give each one its own line. Put each person on a line as soon as a clue allows it.
Pass 2: couples
Next, pair people up. Couples come from three kinds of clue.
- Husband and wife clues, which give a couple directly.
- Two parents of the same child. If H is K's mother and J is the father of K's sister, then J and H are husband and wife.
- In-law words. "I is the son-in-law of K" puts I next to K's daughter. "E is the daughter-in-law of K" puts E next to K's son.
If the puzzle says "there are two married couples", treat it as a count to check against. Once you have found two couples, nobody else in the family is married to a member of the family.
Pass 3: children
Last, hang each child under the couple who are the parents. Brothers and sisters share both parents, so knowing one parent of a child is enough to place a brother or sister beside that child.
For example: Kishan is the husband of Hemlata. Hemlata is the mother of Jairam. Eshna is the wife of Jairam. Gyan is the brother of Jairam. Itika is the granddaughter of Kishan and the daughter of Eshna.
- Generations: Kishan and Hemlata, then Jairam and Gyan, then Itika.
- Couples: Kishan = Hemlata, Jairam = Eshna.
- Children: Jairam and Gyan under Kishan and Hemlata. Itika under Jairam and Eshna.
Kishan (M) = Hemlata (F)
children: Jairam (M) = Eshna (F), Gyan (M)
grandchild: Itika (F)
Now every question is a short walk along these lines. Gyan is Itika's paternal uncle, Hemlata is Eshna's mother-in-law, and Itika is Kishan's son's daughter.
Mark (M), (F) or (?) beside every name as you go. A family puzzle with five or more people should take about 60–75 seconds.
Solved Questions
Question 1
In a family of six members, Gaurav, Hema, Ishaan, Jaya, Kunal and Esha, there are two married couples. Kunal is the father of Ishaan. Hema is the mother of Esha and the wife of Ishaan. Jaya is the wife of Kunal. Gaurav is the brother of Esha. How is Jaya related to Gaurav?
(a) Maternal grandmother (b) Paternal grandmother (c) Mother (d) Father's sister
Answer. Sort the clues before you draw anything.
- Generations: Kunal is Ishaan's father, and Ishaan's wife Hema is Esha's mother. That gives three generations: Kunal, then Ishaan, then Esha and Gaurav.
- Couples: Jaya = Kunal and Ishaan = Hema. Those are the two married couples.
- Children: Esha is Hema's child, so Esha is Ishaan's child too. Gaurav is Esha's brother, so he has the same parents.
Kunal (M) = Jaya (F)
child: Ishaan (M) = Hema (F)
children: Gaurav (M), Esha (?)
From Gaurav: his father is Ishaan, and Ishaan's mother is Jaya. Jaya is Gaurav's father's mother. So the answer is (b) Paternal grandmother.
Question 2
In a family of six members E, G, H, I, J and K, there are two married couples and three generations. J is the father of E. H is the mother of K. E is the wife of G. K is the brother of E. I is the son of G. How is K related to I?
(a) Maternal uncle (b) Paternal uncle (c) Brother (d) Father
Answer. Start with the clue that links two people of the same generation. K is E's brother, so E and K share both parents. J is E's father and H is K's mother, so J and H are the parents of both, and they are one married couple. E = G is the other.
J (M) = H (F)
children: E (F) = G (M), K (M)
grandchild: I (M), son of G and E
From I: his mother is E, and her brother is K. So K is I's mother's brother. "Paternal uncle" would need K to be G's brother. So the answer is (a) Maternal uncle.
Question 3
In a family of seven members, Harish, Komal, Jatin, Ira, Ekta, Farhan and Gita, there are three married couples. Harish and his wife Komal have only two children, a son Jatin and a daughter Ira. Ekta is the daughter-in-law of Harish. Farhan is the son-in-law of Komal. Gita is the daughter of Farhan. Who is the mother of Gita?
(a) Ekta (b) Komal (c) Ira (d) Cannot be determined
Answer. The three couples come straight out of the clues. Harish and his wife Komal are one. A daughter-in-law of Harish is the wife of his son, and his only son is Jatin, so Ekta = Jatin. A son-in-law of Komal is the husband of her daughter, and her only daughter is Ira, so Farhan = Ira.
Harish (M) = Komal (F)
children: Jatin (M) = Ekta (F), and Ira (F) = Farhan (M)
grandchild: Gita (F), daughter of Farhan
Gita's father is Farhan, and Farhan's wife is Ira, so Ira is Gita's mother. Ekta is Gita's aunt by marriage, and Komal is her grandmother. So the answer is (c) Ira.
Question 4
In a family of five members E, G, H, J and K, there are four generations and only one married couple. K is the mother of H. J is the wife of H. E is the daughter of J. G is the son of E. How is K related to G?
(a) Grandmother (b) Mother's mother (c) Great-grandmother (d) Father's mother
Answer. Lay the generations out from the top. K is H's mother. H's wife J is E's mother, so H is E's father. E is G's mother.
K (F)
child: H (M) = J (F)
child: E (F)
child: G (M)
From G, go up: E, then H, then K. Three steps up is a great-grandparent, and K is a woman. "Grandmother" stops one generation short. "Mother's mother" is J, not K. So the answer is (c) Great-grandmother.
Men, Women and Couples
Where genders come from
- Relation words. Brother, son, father, husband, grandson and son-in-law make a man. Sister, daughter, mother, wife, granddaughter and daughter-in-law make a woman. The word belongs to the person it describes: "G is the brother of E" makes G a man and says nothing about E.
- The couple rule. A married couple is one man and one woman. If a child's mother is known and another person is also that child's parent, that person is the father.
- In-law words. If I is K's son-in-law, I is married to K's daughter. If K's children in the family are E, a man, and H, then H must be that daughter.
- Not names. A name that sounds female is not a clue. Go by the words.
Counting men and women
Go down the list of members once and write a gender next to every name, with the clue that fixed it. Then count. Two checks help.
- Each married couple has one man and one woman, so married men and married women are always equal in number.
- If six members make three married couples, everyone is married. So there are exactly three men and three women, even if you cannot yet say which of two people is which.
The member whose gender stays open
Sometimes a person is only ever "the child of" someone or the one that someone else is a "brother of", and no clue says whether this person is a man or a woman. Then:
- A relation question about that person may have "Cannot be determined" as its answer. A brother or sister of a father is either a paternal uncle or a paternal aunt, and the clues do not choose.
- A count of men or women that includes this person cannot be settled. If a count question seems to need a gender that no clue gives, read the clues again. An in-law word, the couple rule or an "only" usually fixes it.
[SSC Tip] Before you answer "how many male members", write (M), (F) or (?) next to every name. A single (?) left over means a clue is still unused.
Solved Questions: Men, Women and Couples
Question 5
In a family of six members E, G, H, I, J and K, there are two married couples. G is the son of J. H is the mother of I. I is the sister of G. K is the wife of G. E is the grandson of H. How many male members are there in the family?
(a) 2 (b) 3 (c) 4 (d) 1
Answer. Go person by person and write each gender with the clue that fixes it.
- G: a son, so (M).
- H: a mother, so (F).
- I: a sister, so (F).
- K: a wife, so (F).
- E: a grandson, so (M).
- J: "G is the son of J" does not fix J. But I is G's sister, so H, I's mother, is G's mother too. G's two parents are J and H, so they are a married couple, and J is the man.
Men: G, E and J. The usual slip is to leave J as unknown and count only two. So the answer is (b) 3.
Question 6
In a family of five members E, G, H, J and K, there is only one married couple. G is the brother of E. J is the father of E. H is the wife of G. K is the son of H. How is E related to K?
(a) Paternal uncle (b) Paternal aunt (c) Maternal uncle (d) Cannot be determined
Answer. Set out the family first. J is the father of E, and G is E's brother, so G is J's son too.
J (M)
children: G (M) = H (F), E (?)
child of G and H: K (M)
E is a brother or sister of K's father. Now look for E's gender. "G is the brother of E" fixes G, not E. "J is the father of E" fixes J. No clue says whether E is a man or a woman. So E could be K's paternal uncle or K's paternal aunt, and the clues do not choose. "Maternal uncle" is wrong in any case, because E is on the father's side. So the answer is (d) Cannot be determined.
Question 7
In a family of eight members, Kishore, Hina, Jayant, Girish, Indu, Garima, Kajal and Juhi, there are three married couples. Hina is the wife of Kishore and has only two children, Jayant and Girish, both sons. Kajal is the daughter of Girish, and Indu is the mother of Kajal. Garima is the daughter-in-law of Hina. Juhi is the granddaughter of Kishore and the daughter of Garima. How many female members are there in the family?
(a) 5 (b) 4 (c) 3 (d) 6
Answer. Mark each gender from the words.
- Kishore: Hina is his wife, so he is (M) and Hina is (F).
- Jayant and Girish: sons, (M).
- Kajal: a daughter, (F). Indu: a mother, (F).
- Garima: a daughter-in-law, (F).
- Juhi: a granddaughter, (F).
The couples are Kishore = Hina, Girish = Indu (they share Kajal), and Jayant = Garima, since a daughter-in-law of Hina must be married to her other son. The count does not need the couples, but they confirm that all eight people fit.
Women: Hina, Indu, Garima, Kajal and Juhi. So the answer is (a) 5.
Question 8
In a family of six members E, G, H, I, J and K, there are two married couples. K is the mother of E and H. G is the son of J. E is the brother of H. I is the son-in-law of K. J is the daughter-in-law of K. Which of the following is a married couple?
(a) E and H (b) J and I (c) H and I (d) K and E
Answer. K is a woman with two children, E and H. E is a brother, so E is a man. No word gives H's gender directly.
I is K's son-in-law, so I is married to K's daughter. K's children in this family are E and H, and E is a man, so H must be the daughter, and H = I.
J is K's daughter-in-law, so she is married to K's son, E. That gives the two couples the question promises. G is J's son.
K (F)
children: E (M) = J (F), and H (F) = I (M)
grandchild: G (M), son of E and J
E and H are brother and sister, and K and E are mother and son. J and I both married into the family, but not to each other. So the answer is (c) H and I.
Counting Families
Some questions describe a whole family in two short sentences and ask for a count: "A man has three sons. Each son is married and has two children. How many members are there in the family?"
Count one generation at a time
| Generation | Who | Count |
|---|---|---|
| Top | the man | 1 |
| Middle | 3 sons and their 3 wives | 6 |
| Bottom | 3 × 2 children | 6 |
Total = 1 + 6 + 6 = 13. If the question says "a man and his wife have three sons", the top line is 2 and the total is 14. If the wife is not mentioned, do not add her.
Say plainly who is included
- "How many members are there in the family?" counts everyone the words mention: the person the story is about, every husband or wife who married in, and every child.
- "How many grandchildren (or granddaughters) does he have?" counts only the bottom line, or only the girls in it.
- "How many children do they have?" counts only their own sons and daughters, not the people those children married.
Common mistakes
- Forgetting the person the story is about. "Firoz has three sons" puts Firoz himself in the family.
- Forgetting those who married in. A married son brings his wife into the count.
- Counting the same person twice. "Hiral has three brothers, and each brother has two sisters" does not mean six sisters. All three brothers have the same two sisters, and Hiral is one of them. So there are 2 girls and 3 boys.
- "Each" shared by everyone. "Each of her sons has one sister" means one sister for all of them together, not one sister for every son.
Write the three lines of the table even when the numbers are small. It takes a few seconds and stops most of these slips.
Solved Questions: Counting Families
Question 9
Firoz and his wife have four sons. Two of the sons are married, and each married son has three children. How many members are there in the family?
(a) 12 (b) 16 (c) 13 (d) 14
Answer. Count one generation at a time.
- Top: Firoz and his wife = 2
- Middle: 4 sons and the 2 wives of the married sons = 6
- Bottom: 2 × 3 = 6 grandchildren
Total = 2 + 6 + 6 = 14. Leaving out the two wives gives 12, and giving all four sons a wife gives 16. So the answer is (d) 14.
Question 10
Girish has two sons and one daughter. Each of his sons has one son and one daughter, and his daughter has two daughters. How many granddaughters does Girish have?
(a) 6 (b) 4 (c) 3 (d) 2
Answer. Granddaughters are the daughters of his children.
- From the two sons: one daughter each, so 2.
- From the daughter: 2.
Total = 2 + 2 = 4. Girish has 6 grandchildren in all, which is why 6 sits among the options. So the answer is (b) 4.
Question 11
Janaki and her husband have two sons and two daughters. Each son is married and has one son and one daughter. Both daughters are unmarried. How many female members are there in the family?
(a) 5 (b) 6 (c) 7 (d) 8
Answer. List the women generation by generation.
- Top: Janaki = 1
- Middle: 2 daughters and the 2 sons' wives = 4
- Bottom: each son has one daughter, so 2
Total = 1 + 4 + 2 = 7. Forgetting the sons' wives gives 5, and forgetting Janaki herself gives 6. So the answer is (c) 7.
Question 12
Ekta has two brothers, and each of her brothers has two sisters. How many children do Ekta's parents have?
(a) 4 (b) 6 (c) 5 (d) 3
Answer. Each brother's two sisters are the same two girls, and Ekta is one of them. So there are 2 girls, Ekta and one more, and 2 boys.
Children = 2 + 2 = 4.
Multiplying 2 brothers by 2 sisters counts the same sisters twice and gives 6. So the answer is (a) 4.
The Question Forms
Once the family is set out, the questions are short. These are the forms you will meet.
1. How is X related to Y?
Walk from Y to X along your lines, naming each step, and turn the path into the word the options use. Watch the direction: "How is X related to Y" and "How is Y related to X" have different answers.
2. Who is the husband (or mother, or father-in-law) of Z?
The options are names. Find Z, take the step the question asks for, and read off the name. The wrong options are usually people one step away in another direction: Z's brother offered as her husband, Z's mother-in-law offered as her mother, Z's own father offered as the father-in-law.
3. Which pair is a married couple?
Check each pair against your couple lines. A brother and sister, a parent and child, or two people of the same gender can be thrown out at once. Two people who both married into the family look like a couple, but they are usually married to different members.
4. How many male (or female) members?
Count the (M)s or the (F)s, but only after every name has a gender. Count the people who married in. They are members too.
5. Which statement is true, or NOT true?
Test each statement against the finished family. A statement is true only if the clues make it certain.
Direct statements inside a puzzle
Some items drop the "family of six members" opening and simply list facts: "G is the brother of E. E is the daughter of H. …" The method is the same, only shorter. A plain list of facts like this should take about 25–35 seconds. A full puzzle with five or more people takes about 60–75 seconds, which is well above the Tier 1 average of 36 seconds a question, so win that time back on the quicker items.
Solved Questions: Puzzles with Five or More People
Question 13
In a family of seven members, Jagdish, Kanta, Eshita, Harsh, Isha, Gagan and Ketan, there are three married couples. Harsh is the son-in-law of Jagdish and the husband of Eshita. Isha is the sister of Eshita. Gagan is married to Isha. Ketan is the son of Gagan. Kanta is the mother of Isha. How is Jagdish related to Ketan?
(a) Paternal grandfather (b) Father (c) Maternal uncle (d) Maternal grandfather
Answer. Harsh is Jagdish's son-in-law and Eshita's husband, so Eshita is Jagdish's daughter. Isha is Eshita's sister, so she is Jagdish's daughter as well. Kanta is Isha's mother, so Jagdish, the other parent, is Kanta's husband and a man. The three couples are Jagdish = Kanta, Harsh = Eshita and Gagan = Isha.
Jagdish (M) = Kanta (F)
children: Eshita (F) = Harsh (M), and Isha (F) = Gagan (M)
grandchild: Ketan (M), son of Gagan and Isha
From Ketan: his mother is Isha, and her father is Jagdish. So Jagdish is Ketan's mother's father.
Time check: three couples and seven people, so give this one the full 60–75 seconds. So the answer is (d) Maternal grandfather.
Question 14
In a family of six members E, G, H, I, J and K, there are two married couples. H is the mother of G and J. G and J are brothers. I is the wife of J. K is the daughter-in-law of H and the mother of E. Who is the father of E?
(a) J (b) G (c) H (d) Cannot be determined
Answer. K is H's daughter-in-law, so she is married to one of H's sons, G or J. J's wife is I, so K is married to G. That gives the two couples: G = K and J = I.
H (F)
children: G (M) = K (F), and J (M) = I (F)
grandchild: E (?), child of K
E's mother is K, and her husband is G. G is E's father, and J is E's uncle. So the answer is (b) G.
Question 15
In a family of six members E, G, H, I, J and K, there are two married couples. G is the brother of H. E is the wife of G. K is the husband of H. I is the son of E. J is the daughter of K. Which of the following statements is true?
(a) K is the brother of G. (b) E is the paternal aunt of J. (c) I is the cousin of J. (d) H is the mother-in-law of E.
Answer. Two couples, one child each.
G (M) = E (F), and H (F) = K (M), with G as H's brother
children: I (M) of G and E, and J (F) of H and K
- K is the husband of G's sister, so he is G's brother-in-law, not his brother.
- E is the wife of J's mother's brother. That makes her J's aunt on the mother's side, not the father's side.
- I's father G and J's mother H are brother and sister, so I and J are cousins. True.
- H is E's husband's sister, so she is E's sister-in-law, not her mother-in-law.
So the answer is (c) I is the cousin of J.
Solved Questions: Mixed Forms
Question 16
In a family of eight members, Gopal, Hansa, Inder, Jyoti, Kabir, Ela, Firoz and Ishita, there are three married couples. Gopal is the husband of Hansa. Inder and Jyoti are the only children of Gopal and Hansa. Kabir is the son-in-law of Hansa. Ela is the wife of Inder. Firoz is the son of Ela, and Ishita is the sister of Firoz. How many male members are there in the family?
(a) 4 (b) 3 (c) 5 (d) 6
Answer. Most genders come straight from the words.
- Gopal, a husband: (M). Hansa, his wife: (F).
- Inder: Ela is his wife, so (M). Ela: (F).
- Kabir, a son-in-law: (M).
- Firoz, a son: (M). Ishita, a sister: (F).
Jyoti is the only one left. Kabir is Hansa's son-in-law, so he is married to Hansa's daughter. Her only children are Inder and Jyoti, and Inder is a man, so Jyoti is the daughter.
Men: Gopal, Inder, Kabir and Firoz. Kabir married into the family, but he is still a member, so count him. So the answer is (a) 4.
Question 17
G is the brother of E. E is the daughter of H. J is the son of G. K is the wife of H. I is the brother of J. How is E related to I?
(a) Mother's sister (b) Grandmother (c) Sister (d) Father's sister
Answer. Start from I. I is J's brother, and J is G's son, so G is I's father too. G is E's brother, and E is H's daughter, so E is a woman.
H (M) = K (F)
children: G (M), E (F)
children of G: J (M), I (M)
E is I's father's sister. K is I's grandmother, but the question is about E.
Time check: a list of plain facts like this should take about 25–35 seconds. So the answer is (d) Father's sister.
Question 18
In a family of seven members, Kailash, Gauri, Eshwar, Ila, Hitesh, Gunjan and Jai, there are three married couples. Jai is the son of Gunjan. Gunjan is the daughter of Ila, and Eshwar is Ila's husband. Hitesh is the father of Jai. Gauri is the mother of Hitesh. Kailash is a grandfather of Jai, but he is not Gunjan's father. Who is the father-in-law of Gunjan?
(a) Eshwar (b) Kailash (c) Hitesh (d) Cannot be determined
Answer. Here two families are joined by one marriage. Gunjan is Jai's mother and Hitesh is his father, so Hitesh = Gunjan.
Jai has two grandfathers: Gunjan's father and Hitesh's father. Gunjan's father is Eshwar, since he is the husband of her mother Ila. Kailash is a grandfather of Jai but not Gunjan's father, so he must be Hitesh's father, and Gauri's husband.
Kailash (M) = Gauri (F), and Eshwar (M) = Ila (F)
their children: Hitesh (M) = Gunjan (F)
grandchild: Jai (M)
A father-in-law is the father of one's husband or wife. Gunjan's husband is Hitesh, and his father is Kailash. Eshwar is her own father. So the answer is (b) Kailash.