A Rough Sheet That Keeps Up With You
Most marks in this chapter are lost while reading, not while thinking. Five facts arrive one after another, and by the fourth one the first has slipped away. A rough sheet that you fill in as fast as you read stops that from happening.
Three marks for gender
Write each name once, the first time it appears, and put a mark after it.
- (M) when a word makes the person male: father, son, brother, husband, uncle, nephew, or "he" and "his".
- (F) when a word makes the person female: mother, daughter, sister, wife, aunt, niece, or "she" and "her".
- ? when no word fixes it yet.
Go by the words, never by the name. In "Lata is a parent of Ojas", Ojas stays "?" until a word such as son or sister turns up. A "?" is not a problem. It reminds you that this gender may decide the answer later, and it stops you from guessing.
One line for each generation
Keep each generation on its own line, the oldest at the top. A married couple sits on one line, joined by "=". Their children go on the next line down.
For example: "Manoj is the husband of Lata. Nisha is the daughter of Lata. Omkar is the brother of Nisha. Pradeep is Manoj's father."
Pradeep (M)
Manoj (M) = Lata (F)
children: Nisha (F), Omkar (M)
Lata is Nisha's mother and Manoj is Lata's husband, so Manoj is Nisha's father too. Omkar is Nisha's brother, so he has the same two parents. That is why both children sit under the couple.
Read the gap off the sheet
Once the sheet is up, count lines instead of rereading words. Pradeep is two lines above Omkar, so he is a grandparent. Manoj and Lata are one line above Nisha. Two people on the same line are brothers and sisters, cousins, a couple, or in-laws.
The count clears options at once. If X sits two lines above Y, every option one generation away (father, mother, uncle, aunt) is out before you think about side or gender.
Hang each fact on a name you already have
Write the first fact, then join each new fact to a name already on the sheet. If a fact brings two new names that join nothing yet, write it to one side. In most stems a later fact joins the two parts, and the side note drops into place.
Folding a Chain from the Speaker
A chain such as "my father's wife's only son's daughter" looks long, but its links fold up in pairs. Learn the common folds and a five-link chain shrinks to one or two links.
Folds to know by heart
| Chain | Folds to |
|---|---|
| Father's wife | Mother |
| Mother's husband | Father |
| Son's sister, daughter's brother | Daughter, son |
| Brother's father, sister's mother | Father, mother |
| Mother's husband's son | Brother, or the speaker himself |
| Wife's father's only daughter | Wife |
| Husband's mother's only son | Husband |
| Wife's mother-in-law | The husband's own mother |
| Paternal grandfather's only son | Father |
| Son's wife | Daughter-in-law |
| Daughter's husband | Son-in-law |
| Father's or mother's brother | Paternal or maternal uncle |
| Uncle's or aunt's child | Cousin |
| Wife's or husband's brother, sister's husband | Brother-in-law |
Each fold rests on two rules that every question in this chapter follows: a couple shares its children, and brothers and sisters share both parents. There are no step-families.
Walk outwards from the speaker
Start at the person the chain hangs from (the "my", or the first name) and fold one pair at a time, moving outwards. Keep only the running answer in your head, never the whole chain.
For example: "Pooja's father's wife's brother's son"
- Pooja's father's wife is Pooja's mother.
- Her mother's brother is her maternal uncle.
- That uncle's son is Pooja's cousin.
Three short steps, and no tree at all.
"Only" is what lets a chain close
"My mother's son" may be a brother. "My mother's only son", said by a man, can only be the man himself. Without the word "only", keep both choices open and let the options decide.
Check who is speaking
The same words fold differently for a man and a woman. A woman's "mother's only son" is her brother. A man's is himself. "My father's only daughter" is the speaker herself if she is a woman, and the speaker's sister if he is a man. Find the speaker's gender in the words ("a man", "her husband", "his wife") before you fold.
[SSC Tip] Underline the word "only" each time it appears in a stem. It often marks the fold that decides the answer.
Coded Questions: Write a Key, Then Read in Pairs
In a coded question, read the definitions once and turn them into a short key. After that, work only from the key and never go back to the definitions.
Make the key
For each symbol write the relation, the gender it gives the first person, and the generation step from the second person to the first.
For example: "'A + B' means 'A is the mother of B', 'A − B' means 'A is the brother of B', 'A × B' means 'A is the wife of B' and 'A ÷ B' means 'A is the father of B'."
| Symbol | A is B's | Gender of A | Step |
|---|---|---|---|
| + | mother | F | one up |
| − | brother | M | same line |
| × | wife | F | same line |
| ÷ | father | M | one up |
Read two people at a time
An expression is read in pairs from left to right. In "O ÷ P × N − L", the pairs are O ÷ P, P × N and N − L. Each pair goes on the sheet as you read it.
- O ÷ P: O is P's father. O (M).
- P × N: P is N's wife. P (F), N (M).
- N − L: N is L's brother.
Now P and N are a couple, N is L's brother, and O sits one line above P. Asked how O is related to L, walk from L: L's brother is N, N's wife is P, and P's father is O. So O is L's brother's wife's father.
Turn reversed definitions round once
Some definitions put the second person first: "'A # B' means 'B is the daughter of A'". Rewrite it on the key in the A-first form: "#: A is B's parent, and B is female". You turn it round once, on the key, instead of at every pair.
Notice what this definition does not say. It fixes B's gender, not A's. A stays "?" unless another pair fixes it.
Fold joined definitions at once
"'A ^ B' means 'A is the brother of B's father'" packs two links into one symbol. Fold it on the key: "^: A is B's paternal uncle (M), one up". When you meet "L ^ N", put an unnamed father above N and L beside him as his brother.
Count the steps
Add up the steps between the two people asked about. If the count says two up, the answer is a grandparent word, and every option one generation away goes at once. Then let the symbols fix the gender and the side.
"Which Expression Shows …": Three Quick Cuts
Here the relation is given and the four options are expressions. Building four families is slow. Three cuts usually leave one option standing, and only that one needs a full reading.
Cut 1: the first symbol
The pair that starts with X has to give X the right gender and the right first link. For "L is the paternal aunt of N", L must be female and must be the sister of someone. So the first symbol must mean sister. Any option that starts with a symbol for mother, wife or brother is out.
Cut 2: the last symbol
The last pair has to end at Y with the link the target needs. "Paternal" usually needs the last link to be "father of N", and "maternal" usually needs "mother of N". A husband or wife link just before N can change that, so read such an option before you cut it. An in-law needs a husband or wife link, often at one end.
Cut 3: the generation count
Count the steps from X to Y in each option still standing. An aunt or uncle needs one up, a grandparent two up, a brother-in-law or sister-in-law none. An option with the wrong count is out even when both ends look right.
For example
Take + for mother, − for sister, × for father and ÷ for wife. Which expression shows that L is the paternal aunt of N?
- L + M × N starts with "mother". Out on cut 1.
- L − M + N starts well, but ends with "mother of N", the maternal side. Out on cut 2.
- L − O × N: L is O's sister and O is N's father. Sister of the father, one up. It stays.
- L ÷ M × N starts with "wife". Out on cut 1.
Only L − O × N is left.
Then read the survivor in full
Middle pairs can still break an option. A brother or sister in the middle keeps the side. A husband or wife in the middle can turn the relation into an in-law. One full reading of the last option settles it, and that is the only full reading you do.
Test the Options, and Use "Cannot Be Determined" With Care
The four options are printed for a reason. Often the quickest route is to check them, not to build the whole family.
Only the path you need
For "How is X related to Y?", draw only the path from Y to X. A person who hangs off the side of that path, such as a cousin of Y or the wife of an unrelated uncle, can stay off the sheet.
Names as options
For "Who is the maternal grandfather of Nayan?", walk from Nayan to the role first: mother, then her father. Then hold each name up against that place. Two of the four names usually fail on gender or generation at a glance.
Statements as options
For "Which of the following is true?" or "Which is NOT correct?", test each statement against the sheet. In a NOT-correct item, three statements hold and one fails. When you find the one that fails, still give the others a quick look, because a misread can make a true statement look false.
When "Cannot be determined" is right
It is the answer only when the facts leave something open and that open point changes the word. Ask two things.
- Check whether a word fixes the gender of the person asked about. Look for he, she, son, sister and the like anywhere in the stem.
- If that gender is open, check whether it changes the word. A child is a son or a daughter, so an open gender matters. A cousin is a cousin either way, so it does not.
For example: "L is the father of M. N is the wife of L. How is M related to N?" M is N's child, but no word fixes M's gender. M could be her son or her daughter, so "Cannot be determined" is right.
If the gender is fixed, or if it does not change the word, "Cannot be determined" is a trap for the student who stopped reading early. Remember that "only" can fix a gender too. If N is M's only brother, any other child of M's parents is a girl.
Watch the side as well
"Maternal" and "paternal" depend on the gender of the parent in the middle. If the stem says only "L is the grandfather of M", the side is open. Look for a word without a side, such as "Grandfather", among the options.
[SSC Tip] Keep the "?" marks on your sheet. If a "?" sits on the person the question asks about, look hard at "Cannot be determined". If it sits on someone else, it usually does not matter.
A Time Plan for This Chapter
The Reasoning section has 25 questions and its own locked 15-minute clock, which is 36 seconds a question on average. A right answer earns 2 marks and a wrong one costs 0.5.
Targets by type
| Type | Target time |
|---|---|
| Direct statements or relation chain | about 25–35 seconds |
| Pointing or introduction | about 30–40 seconds |
| Coded: how is X related to Y | about 40–50 seconds |
| Coded: which expression or which statement | about 50–60 seconds |
| Family puzzle with five or more people | about 60–75 seconds |
The first two types run under the 36-second average. You need that spare time for a coded item or a family puzzle.
Time for each type
- Reading a chain twice. Fold it once, from the speaker, and keep only the running answer.
- Going back to the definitions at every pair. Write the key once.
- Drawing the whole family when the question needs one path.
- Reading all four expressions in full. Make the three cuts first.
When to skip
- you have read a chain twice and still lose your place in the middle
- your sheet for a coded expression contradicts itself after one pass, which usually means a reversed definition read the wrong way
- a family puzzle has passed 75 seconds and two people still have no place
- no option fits at all, which almost always means one misread "of"
Guessing between two
If your cuts have left two options, a guess is worth taking: right half the time for 2 marks, wrong half the time for 0.5 off. A blind guess among four averages only about 0.125 of a mark, so spend those seconds on a question you can finish.
Coming back
Note the question number and the options still alive on your rough sheet. When you return, start from the sheet you already have, not from a blank one.
Solved Questions
Question 1
Lavanya is the sister of Mukesh. Nupur is the daughter of Lavanya. Mukesh is the father of Ojas. Pallavi is the wife of Mukesh. How is Nupur related to Pallavi?
(a) Daughter (b) Niece (c) Sister-in-law (d) Cousin
Answer. Put each name on the sheet the moment it appears, with its mark.
Lavanya (F), Mukesh (M) = Pallavi (F)
children: Nupur (F) under Lavanya, Ojas (?) under Mukesh and Pallavi
Lavanya and Mukesh are sister and brother, so they share a line. Pallavi joins that line as Mukesh's wife. Ojas stays "?" because no word fixes that gender, and the question does not need it.
Now read across. Nupur is one line below Pallavi, so she cannot be a sister-in-law or a cousin of Pallavi. She is not Pallavi's own child either. She is the daughter of Pallavi's husband's sister, and a daughter of your husband's sister is your niece.
Sister-in-law is Lavanya's relation to Pallavi, one step short of Nupur. Cousin is how Nupur is related to Ojas, not to Pallavi. So the answer is (b) Niece.
Question 2
Madhav is the father of Neelam. Omvati is the mother of Madhav. Neelam is the wife of Prakash. Lokesh is the son of Prakash. How is Omvati related to Lokesh?
(a) Grandmother (b) Maternal grandmother (c) Great-grandmother (d) Mother-in-law
Answer. One line for each generation, oldest at the top:
Omvati (F)
Madhav (M)
Neelam (F) = Prakash (M)
Lokesh (M)
Neelam is Prakash's wife and Lokesh is Prakash's son, so Neelam is Lokesh's mother. That puts Lokesh on the line below the couple.
Count lines from Lokesh up to Omvati: Neelam is one, Madhav is two, Omvati is three. Three lines up is a great-grandparent, and the word mother makes Omvati female.
Grandmother is one line short. The maternal grandmother of Lokesh would be Neelam's mother, who is not named here. So the answer is (c) Great-grandmother.
Question 3
How is Mohit's mother's husband's sister's daughter related to Mohit?
(a) Cousin (b) Sister (c) Niece (d) Paternal aunt
Answer. Fold the chain from Mohit outwards, one pair at a time.
Mohit's mother's husband is Mohit's father.
His father's sister is his paternal aunt.
That aunt's daughter is Mohit's cousin.
There is no need to draw anyone else. Paternal aunt is where you stop if you drop the last word. Sister would need the daughter of Mohit's own parents, and the aunt is not his mother. Time check: three folds, well inside 25–35 seconds. So the answer is (a) Cousin.
Question 4
Meera is the wife of Naveen. Pihu is the daughter of the only son of Meera's mother-in-law. How is Pihu related to Naveen?
(a) Niece (b) Sister (c) Daughter (d) Granddaughter
Answer. Meera's mother-in-law is her husband's mother, so she is Naveen's mother.
Naveen is a son of that lady. She has only one son, so "the only son of Meera's mother-in-law" is Naveen himself. Pihu is his daughter.
Niece is the slip of taking the only son to be Naveen's brother, but the word only leaves no room for a brother. Sister comes from reading "the daughter of Meera's mother-in-law" and dropping "the only son". So the answer is (c) Daughter.
Question 5
Looking at a photograph of a boy, Omkar told his wife, "He is the son of my sister's only brother." How is Omkar related to the boy?
(a) Son (b) Paternal uncle (c) Brother-in-law (d) Father
Answer. "Told his wife" makes Omkar a man. So Omkar is a brother of his own sister. She has only one brother, so "my sister's only brother" is Omkar himself, and the boy is Omkar's son.
Now look at which way the question runs. It asks how Omkar is related to the boy, not how the boy is related to Omkar. Omkar is the boy's father. Son is the same relation read the other way round. Paternal uncle is what you get if you take the only brother to be some other man, but the word only leaves no room for him. So the answer is (d) Father.
Question 6
Pointing to a boy, Leela said to her friend, "His father is the only son of my mother." How is the boy related to Leela?
(a) Son (b) Nephew (c) Brother (d) Cousin
Answer. Fix the speaker first. "Said to her friend" tells you Leela is a woman.
A woman's mother's only son cannot be the woman herself, so it is Leela's brother. The boy's father is Leela's brother, and a son of your brother is your nephew.
Son is the answer you get if you fold "my mother's only son" to the speaker, as you would for a man. The words here rule that out. So the answer is (b) Nephew.
Question 7
In a certain code language,
'A + B' means 'A is the mother of B';
'A − B' means 'A is the brother of B';
'A × B' means 'A is the wife of B';
'A ÷ B' means 'A is the father of B'.
Based on the above, how is N related to L if 'N + P − O ÷ L'?
(a) Paternal grandmother (b) Mother (c) Maternal grandmother (d) Father's sister
Answer. Write the key once:
- '+' : mother, F, one up
- '−' : brother, M, same line
- '×' : wife, F, same line
- '÷' : father, M, one up
Read in pairs. N + P: N is P's mother. P − O: P is O's brother, so N is O's mother as well. O ÷ L: O is L's father.
Count the steps from L up to N. O is one up, P sits on O's line, and N is one up again. Two up means a grandparent, and + makes N female.
The parent in the middle is O, a father, so the side is paternal. Mother is one generation short, and maternal grandmother picks the wrong side. So the answer is (a) Paternal grandmother.
Question 8
'A @ B' means 'B is the son of A'.
'A # B' means 'A is the brother of B's mother'.
'A & B' means 'A is the husband of B'.
If 'L & M @ N # O', how is L related to O?
(a) Paternal grandfather (b) Maternal grandfather (c) Father-in-law (d) Mother's brother
Answer. Turn the key into A-first form before reading anything.
- '@' : A is B's parent, and B is male (B is the son)
- '#' : A is B's mother's brother, so A is B's maternal uncle, one up
- '&' : A is B's husband
Now the pairs. L & M: L is M's husband. M @ N: N is M's son. N # O: N is the brother of O's mother.
So O's mother is N's sister. She is also a child of L and M. That makes L the father of O's mother: O's maternal grandfather.
Mother's brother is N's relation to O, not L's. Father-in-law would need O to be married into L's family, and nothing says so. So the answer is (b) Maternal grandfather.
Question 9
In a certain code language, 'A × B' means 'A is the mother of B', 'A − B' means 'A is the sister of B', 'A ÷ B' means 'A is the father of B' and 'A + B' means 'A is the son of B'. Which of the following expressions shows that L is the maternal grandmother of P?
(a) L × M ÷ P (b) L − M × P (c) L + N × P (d) L × N − M × P
Answer. Make the three cuts.
Cut 1, the first symbol. L must be female and a mother, so the expression must start with L ×. Option (b) starts with "sister" and option (c) with "son". Both are out.
Cut 2, the last symbol. "Maternal" needs the last link to be "mother of P", which is × P. Option (a) ends with ÷ P, "father of P". Out.
Only (d) is left, so read it in full. L × N: L is N's mother. N − M: N is M's sister, so L is M's mother too. M × P: M is P's mother. L is the mother of P's mother.
Time check: the cuts took two glances, and only one expression was read in full. That keeps this inside 50–60 seconds. So the answer is (d) L × N − M × P.
Question 10
'A @ B' means 'A is the brother of B'.
'A # B' means 'A is the daughter of B'.
'A & B' means 'A is the husband of B'.
'A % B' means 'A is the mother of B'.
If 'M @ N # O & P % L', which of the following statements is correct?
(a) M is the son of P. (b) O is the brother of M. (c) N is the mother of L. (d) P is the wife of M.
Answer. Read the pairs onto the sheet. M @ N: M is N's brother. N # O: N is O's daughter. O & P: O is P's husband. P % L: P is L's mother.
O (M) = P (F)
children: M (M), N (F), L (?)
O and P are a couple, so N is P's daughter as well. M is N's brother, so he is their son. L is P's child, so L is a brother or sister of M and N.
Now test each statement against the sheet. M is the son of P: true. O is M's father, not his brother. N is L's sister, not L's mother. P is M's mother, not his wife.
Only one statement holds, so there is nothing more to check. So the answer is (a) M is the son of P.
Question 11
Mitali is the wife of Nikhil. Om is Nikhil's brother. Pihu is the daughter of Om. Lekha is the wife of Om. Who is the sister-in-law of Pihu's father?
(a) Lekha (b) Mitali (c) Pihu (d) Cannot be determined
Answer. Walk from Pihu to the role first. Pihu's father is Om. A sister-in-law of Om is his wife's sister or his brother's wife.
Now hold each name up against that.
Lekha is Om's wife, not his sister-in-law.
Mitali is the wife of Nikhil, and Nikhil is Om's brother. A brother's wife is a sister-in-law, so she fits.
Pihu is Om's daughter.
One name fits, so nothing is left open. So the answer is (b) Mitali.
Question 12
L is the father of M. N is the brother of M. O is the wife of L. P is a child of O. How is P related to N?
(a) Brother (b) Cousin (c) Sister (d) Cannot be determined
Answer. Put the marks down.
L (M) = O (F)
children: M (?), N (M), P (?)
O is L's wife, so she is the mother of M and N as well. P is O's child, and a couple shares its children, so P is a third child of the same couple. That makes P a brother or sister of N.
Now the two checks for "Cannot be determined". Does a word fix P's gender? No word does: "child" says nothing about it. Does that open gender change the answer? Yes. P is N's brother if P is a boy and N's sister if P is a girl.
Cousin is out, because P has the same parents as N. Brother and Sister each fit only one reading. So the answer is (d) Cannot be determined.
Question 13
In a family of six members, Laxman, Mamta, Nitin, Nandita, Ojasvi and Parth, there are two married couples. Laxman is the grandfather of Ojasvi. Mamta is the mother of Parth. Nandita is the daughter-in-law of Laxman. Parth is the brother of Nitin. Ojasvi is the daughter of Nitin. Parth is not married. How is Parth related to Nandita?
(a) Brother-in-law (b) Husband (c) Father-in-law (d) Cannot be determined
Answer. Start from the couples, because they fix everything else.
Nandita is Laxman's daughter-in-law, so she is married to one of Laxman's sons. Parth is not married. Ojasvi is a daughter, and Laxman cannot be his own son. That leaves Nitin as Nandita's husband.
The second couple must come from Laxman, Mamta, Parth and Ojasvi. Parth is single and Ojasvi is a grandchild, so it is Laxman and Mamta. Mamta is Parth's mother, and Parth is Nitin's brother, so they are both sons of Laxman and Mamta.
Laxman (M) = Mamta (F)
Nitin (M) = Nandita (F), Parth (M)
Ojasvi (F)
Parth is the brother of Nandita's husband, so he is her brother-in-law. Every gender and every link here is fixed, so "Cannot be determined" is only a trap. Time check: the couples took most of the time, and the answer came in one look, well inside 60–75 seconds. So the answer is (a) Brother-in-law.
Question 14
Pramod lives with his mother, his wife and their two sons. Each son is married and has two daughters and one son. No one else lives in the family. How many female members are there in the family?
(a) 7 (b) 6 (c) 8 (d) 10
Answer. Count the women one generation at a time, so nobody is missed.
Top line: Pramod's mother, 1
Pramod's line: his wife, 1
Sons' line: the wives of the two sons, 2
Bottom line: two daughters for each son, 2 × 2 = 4
Female members = 1 + 1 + 2 + 4 = 8
7 forgets Pramod's mother. 6 forgets the two daughters-in-law, an easy slip because they married into the family. 10 counts all six grandchildren as girls. So the answer is (c) 8.