Courses of Action: What Should Be Done?

A course-of-action question describes a problem, or a situation that needs a response. Two or three suggested actions follow, numbered I, II and III. You decide which of them should be taken.

Take everything in the statement as true. You are not asked whether the problem is real. You are asked whether each action is a sensible response to it.

Four tests for an action

An action follows only if it passes all four tests.

  1. It deals with the problem. It solves it, makes it smaller, gives relief to the people hit by it, or stops it from happening again. It does not have to solve the whole problem.
  2. It is practical. It can be done with ordinary effort and in reasonable time.
  3. It is in the hands of the one acting. A hospital can buy beds. It cannot change the country's laws.
  4. It is in proportion. The size of the step fits the size of the problem. A few complaints do not call for shutting everything down.

One statement, many actions

Statement: Visitors to the district hospital in Town P cannot find their way to the wards, because there are no signboards inside the building.

Suggested action Verdict Why
Put up clear signboards on every floor and at every corner. Follows Fixes the problem directly.
Keep a help desk at the entrance to guide visitors. Follows Gives visitors help at once.
Stop letting visitors into the hospital. Does not follow Extreme. It removes visitors instead of guiding them.
Paint the outer wall of the hospital. Does not follow Unrelated. Visitors are still lost inside.
Ask visitors to remember the way from their last visit. Does not follow A wish. First-time visitors have no last visit.
Get a national law passed on hospital signboards. Does not follow Not in the hospital's power.

The first two rows both follow. They do different jobs, and the hospital can do both. Do not treat the actions as rivals where only one can win.

Complaints, inquiries and punishment

When many people complain, looking into the complaints is a sensible first step, because it finds the fault so that it can be fixed. Action against a person who has been found at fault also follows, as long as it is under the rules. Punishing a whole group because one member did wrong is out of proportion. So is closing a whole trade because a few shops broke the rules.

Solved Questions

Question 1

In this question, a statement is followed by two courses of action, numbered I and II. You must assume everything in the statement to be true and, on the basis of the information given in the statement, decide which of the courses of action logically follow(s) for pursuing.

Statement:

Many passengers at the main bus stand of City K complain that there is no drinking water on any of its platforms.

Courses of action:

I. The bus stand authority should set up drinking water points on the platforms.

II. The bus stand authority should stop all buses from leaving City K until the water points are ready.

(a) Only I follows (b) Only II follows (c) Both I and II follow (d) Neither I nor II follows

Answer. The problem is plain: no drinking water on the platforms. Setting up water points fixes exactly that, and the bus stand can easily do it, so I follows.

II stops every bus in the city over a water problem. That hurts every traveller in the city and is far out of proportion, so II does not follow.

So the answer is (a) Only I follows.

Question 2

In this question, a statement is followed by two courses of action, numbered I and II. You must assume everything in the statement to be true and, on the basis of the information given in the statement, decide which of the courses of action logically follow(s) for pursuing.

Statement:

The only lift in the outpatient building of the district hospital in Town L has been out of order for two days, and elderly patients are finding it hard to climb to the doctors' rooms on the third floor.

Courses of action:

I. The hospital should get the lift repaired as soon as possible.

II. Until the lift works again, doctors should see elderly patients in a room on the ground floor.

(a) Only I follows (b) Only II follows (c) Both I and II follow (d) Neither I nor II follows

Answer. I fixes the problem at its root, so it follows.

II does not repair anything, but it gives elderly patients relief until the lift is fixed, and a ground-floor room is easy to arrange. Giving relief to the people hit by a problem counts as dealing with it, so II follows too.

The two actions do different jobs, and the hospital can do both.

So the answer is (c) Both I and II follow.

Question 3

In this question, a statement is followed by two courses of action, numbered I and II. You must assume everything in the statement to be true and, on the basis of the information given in the statement, decide which of the courses of action logically follow(s) for pursuing.

Statement:

Some passengers on the night trains between City A and City B have complained that the toilets in their coaches were not cleaned during the journey.

Courses of action:

I. All night trains between City A and City B should be cancelled until the complaints stop.

II. Passengers on night trains should be told not to use the toilets.

(a) Only I follows (b) Only II follows (c) Both I and II follow (d) Neither I nor II follows

Answer. Cancelling every night train because some toilets were not cleaned is far too strong a step. It punishes every passenger and does nothing about the cleaning, so I does not follow.

II asks passengers to go a whole night without a toilet. That is not practical, and the dirty toilets stay as they are, so II does not follow either.

A sensible step would be to have the toilets cleaned during the journey, but that is not one of the choices.

So the answer is (d) Neither I nor II follows.

Solved Questions: More Courses of Action

Question 4

In this question, a statement is followed by two courses of action, numbered I and II. You must assume everything in the statement to be true and, on the basis of the information given in the statement, decide which of the courses of action logically follow(s) for pursuing.

Statement:

Several people have been hurt this year while crossing the busy Ring Road of City S near the vegetable market, where there is no zebra crossing or traffic signal.

Courses of action:

I. The city council should plant more trees along the Ring Road.

II. The city council should put a zebra crossing and a traffic signal at that spot.

(a) Only I follows (b) Only II follows (c) Both I and II follow (d) Neither I nor II follows

Answer. The problem is people getting hurt while crossing at one busy spot. Trees along the road may be pleasant, but they do nothing for people crossing it, so I is unrelated and does not follow.

A zebra crossing and a signal let people cross safely at exactly that spot, and the council has the power to put them up. II follows.

So the answer is (b) Only II follows.

Question 5

In this question, a statement is followed by three courses of action, numbered I, II and III. You must assume everything in the statement to be true and, on the basis of the information given in the statement, decide which of the courses of action logically follow(s) for pursuing.

Statement:

A bus driver on Route 12 of City D was caught driving a full bus while talking on his mobile phone.

Courses of action:

I. The bus company should take action against the driver under its rules.

II. The bus company should remind all its drivers that using a phone while driving is not allowed.

III. The bus company should stop running buses on Route 12.

(a) Only III follows (b) Only I and II follow (c) Only II and III follow (d) All I, II and III follow

Answer. The driver was caught breaking a safety rule, so action against him under the company's rules is fair. I follows.

A reminder to all drivers helps stop the same thing from happening again, so II follows too.

Stopping the whole route punishes every passenger on it for one driver's mistake. III is out of proportion.

Time check: with three parts, mark each part once and then find the option that matches all three marks.

So the answer is (b) Only I and II follow.

Question 6

In this question, a statement is followed by two courses of action, numbered I and II. You must assume everything in the statement to be true and, on the basis of the information given in the statement, decide which of the courses of action logically follow(s) for pursuing.

Statement:

The free pharmacy of the government hospital in Town G runs out of common medicines in the last week of almost every month.

Courses of action:

I. The hospital should decide the prices that medicine companies charge across the whole country.

II. The hospital should order larger stocks each month, based on how much was used in earlier months.

(a) Only I follows (b) Only II follows (c) Both I and II follow (d) Neither I nor II follows

Answer. One hospital cannot decide what medicine companies charge across the country. That is beyond its power, and it does not touch the stock problem anyway, so I does not follow.

Ordering more, based on how much was used before, stops the pharmacy from running out at the end of the month. II follows.

So the answer is (b) Only II follows.

Arguments: Strong or Weak?

An argument question asks a "Should …?" question and gives two arguments, usually one starting with "Yes" and one with "No". You decide which arguments are strong. You are not deciding how you would vote. Both a "Yes" and a "No" can be strong at the same time, and both can be weak.

What makes an argument strong

A strong argument does three things:

  • it is about the exact question asked,
  • it points to something that matters, such as health, safety, money, time or people's living,
  • it gives a reason that holds up, usually a clear result of saying yes or no.

For example: "Should food stalls at the bus stands of Town N be told to keep cooked food covered? Yes, covered food is less likely to be spoiled by dust and flies." It is on the question, it is about health, and the reason is sound. That makes it strong.

Signs of a weak argument

Kind What it sounds like
Superlative or sweeping "Yes, it is the best plan ever." "Everyone in the town wants it."
Copying another place "Yes, City Q did it last year."
Habit "No, we have always done it this way."
Trivial "No, the new signboards will not match the old ones."
Vague "Yes, it will be good for everyone."
Off the question It talks about something close to the issue, not the issue itself.
Taste or feeling "No, people do not like change."

A weak argument may still be true. City Q may really have done it last year. The argument is weak because it gives no reason why the step is right here.

Strengthen or weaken

In another form you get a claim (printed as the statement) and two arguments. Take each argument in turn and ask one thing: if this is true, does the claim become more likely or less likely?

  • A fact that backs the claim, or shows the claimed result really happening, strengthens it.
  • A fact that shows a failure, a harm, or a different explanation for the result weakens it.

For example, take the claim "The new evening clinic at Town R's hospital is useful for working people." "Most patients at the evening clinic come straight from work" strengthens it. "The evening clinic shuts at 5 p.m., before most offices close" weakens it.

Both arguments can strengthen, both can weaken, or one can do each. Judge each argument against the claim, not against the other argument.

Solved Questions: Arguments

Question 7

A question is followed by two arguments I and II. Decide which of the arguments is/are strong.

Question:

Should all two-wheeler riders in Town N be required to wear helmets?

Arguments:

I. Yes, a helmet lowers the chance of a serious head injury if the rider falls.

II. No, many riders do not like the way they look in helmets.

(a) Only argument I is strong (b) Only argument II is strong (c) Both I and II are strong (d) Neither I nor II is strong

Answer. I is directly about the question and gives a serious reason: a helmet protects the head in a fall. I is strong.

II is about how riders look. Looks are a trivial matter next to safety, so II is weak.

So the answer is (a) Only argument I is strong.

Question 8

A question is followed by two arguments I and II. Decide which of the arguments is/are strong.

Question:

Should the night bus service between City U and City W, which usually runs nearly empty, be stopped?

Arguments:

I. Yes, running a nearly empty bus every night wastes fuel and money that the bus company could spend on its busy routes.

II. No, the few people who use it, such as hospital staff coming off night shifts, have no other way to travel at that hour.

(a) Only argument I is strong (b) Only argument II is strong (c) Both I and II are strong (d) Neither I nor II is strong

Answer. I is strong. Fuel and money are real costs, and they could serve routes that people do use.

II is strong too. It names real people who would be left with no way home at night.

Each argument gives a sound reason for its own side. An argument does not become weak just because the other side also has a good point.

So the answer is (c) Both I and II are strong.

Question 9

A question is followed by two arguments I and II. Decide which of the arguments is/are strong.

Question:

Should the canteens of all hospitals in City D serve only boiled food?

Arguments:

I. Yes, boiled food is the best food in the world.

II. No, the people of City D have always liked fried snacks.

(a) Only argument I is strong (b) Only argument II is strong (c) Both I and II are strong (d) Neither I nor II is strong

Answer. I uses a superlative, "the best food in the world". That is a slogan, not a reason.

II only says what people have always liked. Habit is no reason for hospitals to decide what to serve.

Both arguments are weak.

So the answer is (d) Neither I nor II is strong.

Question 10

A question is followed by two arguments I and II. Decide which of the arguments is/are strong.

Question:

Should private cars be banned from all roads in City R on weekdays?

Arguments:

I. Yes, City Q, next door, banned private cars on weekdays last year.

II. No, a full ban would also stop people who need a car to rush a sick person to hospital.

(a) Only argument I is strong (b) Only argument II is strong (c) Both I and II are strong (d) Neither I nor II is strong

Answer. I says only that a neighbouring city did it. What City Q did is no reason why it is right for City R, so I is weak.

II points to a serious harm of a full ban: people in a medical emergency would be stopped too. II is strong.

So the answer is (b) Only argument II is strong.

Solved Questions: Strengthen or Weaken

Question 11

A statement is followed by two arguments I and II. Read the statement and the arguments carefully and select the appropriate answer.

Statement:

A separate bus lane on Station Road of City T will cut the time buses take to travel along that road.

Arguments:

I. On Station Road, buses lose most of their travel time stuck behind cars and two-wheelers in slow traffic.

II. During a one-week trial of a bus lane on Station Road, buses took 35 minutes for a trip that usually takes 50 minutes.

(a) Both I and II strengthen the statement. (b) I strengthens while II weakens the statement. (c) I weakens while II strengthens the statement. (d) Both I and II weaken the statement.

Answer. The claim is that a bus lane will cut bus travel time.

I says the time is lost behind other traffic, which is exactly what a bus lane takes away. So I makes the claim more likely.

II shows a bus lane actually cutting the trip from 50 minutes to 35 in a trial, so II backs the claim too.

So the answer is (a) Both I and II strengthen the statement.

Question 12

A statement is followed by two arguments I and II. Read the statement and the arguments carefully and select the appropriate answer.

Statement:

The new footbridge at Station K has made it safer for passengers to move between platforms.

Arguments:

I. In the year since the footbridge opened, no passenger has been hurt while crossing the tracks at Station K, against nine passengers hurt in the year before.

II. At peak hours the footbridge is so crowded that many passengers still climb down onto the tracks to cross.

(a) Both I and II strengthen the statement. (b) I strengthens while II weakens the statement. (c) I weakens while II strengthens the statement. (d) Both I and II weaken the statement.

Answer. I shows injuries on the tracks falling from nine to none after the footbridge opened, so it supports the claim.

II shows many passengers still crossing the tracks at peak hours, which is the very danger the footbridge was meant to end. So II weakens the claim.

So the answer is (b) I strengthens while II weakens the statement.

Cause and Effect

These questions come in three shapes. In all three you ask the same thing: does one event really lead to the other?

Shape 1: a cause and its possible effects

You get a cause and two or three effects. An effect must

  • follow directly from the cause,
  • come after the cause in time,
  • be what a sensible person would expect.

Cause: A fault at the fuel depot kept most of City M's buses off the roads on Tuesday.

"More people than usual took auto-rickshaws in City M on Tuesday" is an effect. "City M raised its bus fares last year" is not, because it happened before the cause. "A new hospital opened in City M" is not either, since a fuel fault has nothing to do with it.

Read the time words with care: today, last week, next month. An event that happened before the cause can never be its effect, however closely it seems linked.

Shape 2: an observation and its possible reasons

Here the statement is something that has been noticed, and you test each reason. A reason works if, being true, it would plausibly bring about what was noticed. It fails if it is unrelated, or if it would push things the other way.

Statement: A roadside eatery in Town P has had far more customers this month.

"A busy bus stop was moved right in front of the eatery at the start of the month" is a possible reason. "The owner of the eatery bought a new car" is not.

Shape 3: two events

You get two statements and decide how they are linked.

Choice What it means
I is the cause and II is its effect I happened and led to II.
II is the cause and I is its effect The same, the other way round.
Independent causes Each may lead to something, but they are not linked to each other.
Effects of independent causes Each has its own separate cause.
Effects of a common cause One unstated event led to both.

For example: "I. Most traffic signals in City Y stopped working for two hours on Friday evening. II. Long jams formed at many crossings in City Y on Friday evening." The signals failed, and the jams followed. I is the cause and II is its effect.

Do not assume the statement printed first is the cause. Check which event happened first, then ask whether it could have led to the other.

[SSC Tip] An effect that sounds sensible but is dated before the cause is a planted trap. Check the time words before anything else.

Solved Questions: Causes and Effects

Question 13

Given below is a statement (Cause) followed by possible effects numbered I, II and III. Read the 'Cause' carefully and decide which of the three can be possible effect/s.

Cause:

A new bypass that lets trucks go round Town H, instead of through the middle of the town, opened last week.

Effects:

I. Fewer trucks have passed through the middle of Town H this week.

II. People who live in the middle of Town H say their streets have been less noisy this week.

III. The main road through the middle of Town H was widened five years ago.

(a) Only I is a possible effect (b) Both I and II are possible effects (c) Both II and III are possible effects (d) All I, II and III are possible effects

Answer. With a road round the town, trucks no longer need to pass through its middle, so I is a direct effect.

Fewer heavy trucks rumbling along those streets means less noise for the people who live there, so II is a sensible effect too.

III happened five years before the bypass opened, so it cannot be an effect of it.

So the answer is (b) Both I and II are possible effects.

Question 14

Given below is a statement (Cause) followed by possible effects numbered I, II and III. Read the 'Cause' carefully and decide which of the three can be possible effect/s.

Cause:

From this Monday, the town hospital of Town C has started a free ambulance service for the whole town.

Effects:

I. The hospital's ambulance number has received many more calls this week than before.

II. Last month, many people in Town C complained that private ambulances charged too much.

III. Private ambulance owners in Town C have had fewer bookings this week.

(a) Only I is a possible effect (b) Only III is a possible effect (c) Both I and III are possible effects (d) Both II and III are possible effects

Answer. Read the time words first. The free service started this Monday.

More calls to the hospital's ambulance number this week is just what you would expect, so I is an effect.

II happened last month, before the service started, so it cannot be its effect. If anything, it may be part of the reason the service was started.

Private ambulances losing bookings to a free service this week is a sensible effect, so III counts.

So the answer is (c) Both I and III are possible effects.

Question 15

Given below is a statement followed by two possible reasons numbered I and II. Read the statement carefully and decide which of the two explain(s) the event or observation given in the statement.

Statement:

Over the past month, the time patients spend waiting at the registration counter of Hospital R has fallen from about two hours to about thirty minutes.

Reasons:

I. At the start of the month, Hospital R opened three more registration counters.

II. At the start of the month, Hospital R changed the colour of its registration slips from white to yellow.

(a) Only I is a possible reason (b) Only II is a possible reason (c) Both I and II are possible reasons (d) Neither I nor II is a possible reason

Answer. Three more counters means the queue is shared among more staff, so each patient waits less. I is a possible reason.

The colour of the slip does not change how fast a patient is registered, so II is not.

So the answer is (a) Only I is a possible reason.

Solved Questions: Reasons and Two Events

Question 16

Given below is a statement followed by two possible reasons numbered I and II. Read the statement carefully and decide which of the two explain(s) the event or observation given in the statement.

Statement:

Fewer people are travelling by the morning train from Town D to City E this year than last year.

Reasons:

I. A new highway has cut the bus journey between Town D and City E from three hours to ninety minutes.

II. The fare of the morning train from Town D to City E has been doubled this year.

(a) Only I is a possible reason (b) Only II is a possible reason (c) Both I and II are possible reasons (d) Neither I nor II is a possible reason

Answer. A much faster bus journey would pull some passengers away from the train, so I can explain the drop.

A doubled fare would also push some people off the train, so II can explain it too.

So the answer is (c) Both I and II are possible reasons.

Question 17

Two statements, I and II, are given below. They may be independent causes, effects of independent causes or effects of a common cause, or one of them may be the effect of the other. Read both statements and decide which answer choice correctly describes the relationship between them.

Statements:

I. The main market road of Town F was closed for a week for resurfacing.

II. Traffic on the side lanes of Town F was much heavier than usual that week.

(a) Statement I is the cause and statement II is its effect. (b) Statement II is the cause and statement I is its effect. (c) Both statements I and II are independent causes. (d) Both statements I and II are effects of a common cause.

Answer. The market road was closed, so the vehicles that normally use it had to go through the side lanes. That made the side lanes much busier that same week.

I came first and led to II.

So the answer is (a) Statement I is the cause and statement II is its effect.

Question 18

Two statements, I and II, are given below. They may be independent causes, effects of independent causes or effects of a common cause, or one of them may be the effect of the other. Read both statements and decide which answer choice correctly describes the relationship between them.

Statements:

I. On Sunday night, doctors at the town hospital of Town J treated more than forty visitors to the town fair for food poisoning.

II. On Sunday evening, a food stall at the Town J fair served chicken that had gone bad to a large crowd of visitors.

(a) Statement I is the cause and statement II is its effect. (b) Statement II is the cause and statement I is its effect. (c) Both statements I and II are independent causes. (d) Both statements I and II are effects of a common cause.

Answer. The bad chicken was served on Sunday evening, and fair visitors were treated for food poisoning that same night. Eating spoiled food is a common cause of food poisoning, so II led to I.

Notice that the cause is printed second here. Do not take the first statement as the cause just because it comes first.

So the answer is (b) Statement II is the cause and statement I is its effect.

A Routine for Each Type, and the Options

Courses of action

  1. Put the problem into a few words: "lost visitors", "unsafe crossing", "no water on platforms".
  2. Name who would act: the hospital, the bus company, the town council.
  3. Run each action through the four tests: it deals with the problem, it is practical, it is in that actor's power, and it is in proportion.

Arguments

  1. Read the question and note its exact scope: which town, which group, all or some.
  2. For each argument, check that it gives a real reason about that exact question.
  3. Watch for the weak signs: best, all, always, another city, habit, taste.
  4. In the strengthen/weaken form, ask only whether the argument makes the claim more likely or less likely.

Cause and effect

  1. Fix the time of the cause.
  2. For each effect, check three things: it comes after the cause, it is directly linked, and a sensible person would expect it.
  3. For reasons, ask whether the reason, if true, would bring about what was noticed.
  4. For two events, find which happened first, then ask whether the first could lead to the second.

The option sets

The options use a few fixed sets of words. Learn to read them at a glance.

Type Options look like
Courses of action Only I follows / Only II follows / Both I and II follow / Neither I nor II follows
Three courses of action Only I and II follow / Only III follows / All I, II and III follow …
Arguments Only argument I is strong / Only argument II is strong / Both I and II are strong / Neither I nor II is strong
Strengthen or weaken I strengthens while II weakens the statement / Both I and II strengthen the statement …
Effects Only I is a possible effect / Both I and III are possible effects / All I, II and III are possible effects …
Reasons Only I is a possible reason / Both I and II are possible reasons …

Make your verdict on every numbered part first. Put a small tick or cross next to each, and only then look at the options. With three parts, one cross often rules out two options at once.

The order of the options changes from question to question, so match the words, not the position.

These questions should take about 35–45 seconds each. In Tier 1 the Reasoning section has 25 questions on its own locked 15-minute clock, which is 36 seconds a question on average. A verbal item that takes a full minute is borrowing time from the next question.

Solved Questions: Mixed Practice

Question 19

In this question, a statement is followed by two courses of action, numbered I and II. You must assume everything in the statement to be true and, on the basis of the information given in the statement, decide which of the courses of action logically follow(s) for pursuing.

Statement:

Many elderly people in Town K do not know that the town hospital gives free eye check-ups every Saturday.

Courses of action:

I. The hospital should put up notices about the Saturday check-ups at bus stops, markets and its own gate.

II. The hospital should ask the health workers who visit homes in Town K to tell elderly people about the check-ups.

(a) Only I follows (b) Only II follows (c) Both I and II follow (d) Neither I nor II follows

Answer. The problem is that elderly people have not heard about the free check-ups.

Notices at busy places spread the word, so I follows.

Health workers who already visit homes can tell elderly people in person, which reaches those who may not read notices, so II follows too. Both steps are practical and in the hospital's hands.

So the answer is (c) Both I and II follow.

Question 20

Given below is a statement (Cause) followed by possible effects numbered I, II and III. Read the 'Cause' carefully and decide which of the three can be possible effect/s.

Cause:

From the first of this month, the bus company of City N has cut all its fares by half.

Effects:

I. Last month, the bus company bought twenty new buses.

II. More people in City N are travelling by bus this month than last month.

III. The price of rice in City N has gone up this month.

(a) Only I is a possible effect (b) Only II is a possible effect (c) Both II and III are possible effects (d) All I, II and III are possible effects

Answer. The fare cut began on the first of this month. Buses bought last month came before it, so I is not an effect.

Cheaper fares would bring more people onto the buses, so II is a direct effect.

Bus fares have nothing to do with the price of rice, so III is not an effect.

So the answer is (b) Only II is a possible effect.