How to Use This Section

This is a longer mixed set of 32 questions. All eight types from the chapter turn up in no fixed order, and most are a level above Sections 1 to 4. Some have three numbered parts instead of two. Some end in an either-or. Some courses of action put a sensible step next to one that goes too far, and some assumptions sit behind an advertisement or a public appeal. The data sufficiency questions need two small steps of reasoning before a statement gives the answer.

A harder question here still has one clear answer. Every key rests on the same rules as before: take the statement as true, use nothing outside it except plain everyday knowledge, and judge each part by the one-line test for its type. If you catch yourself defending an answer with "but in real life …", go back to the statement and read what it actually says.

Cover the answer, decide every part, pick an option, and only then read on. Check your reasons as well as your option. If you reached the right option for a wrong reason, count it as a miss, because a wrong reason will fail you on the next question.

Keep the exam targets in view: about 25–35 seconds for an inequality or comparison question, 35–45 seconds for a statement–conclusion, assumption or inference question, 35–45 seconds for a course-of-action, argument or cause-and-effect question, and 45–60 seconds for a data sufficiency question. Three-part items will run over the first time. Note which ones did, and try them again from a blank sheet a few days later.

Three habits help all through the set. Settle the clearest part first and strike the options it rules out. In an inequality, join the statements once and walk only the stretch you need. In data sufficiency, test each statement alone with the other one covered before you put them together.

Solved Questions

Question 1

Decide which of the conclusions logically follow(s) from the statement.

Statement:

The panchayat of Village K has announced that from 1 June, a new tap connection will be given only to households that have built a soak pit for their waste water.

Conclusions:

I. From 1 June, a household in Village K that has no soak pit will not be given a new tap connection.

II. Every household in Village K already has a tap connection.

III. Most households in Village K have already built a soak pit.

(a) Only I follows (b) Only I and III follow (c) Only II and III follow (d) All three follow

Answer. Settle the clearest part first. "Only" sits in the statement itself, and it shuts out every household without a soak pit. I says exactly that from the other side, so I follows. That already strikes "Only II and III follow".

II brings in a new fact about every household in the village. The notice says nothing about who has a tap today, so II does not follow, and "All three follow" goes with it.

III is the tempting one, because a rule like this is often made once most people already follow it. But the notice says nothing about how many households have a soak pit, so III brings in a new fact and does not follow. So the answer is (a) Only I follows.

Question 2

Decide which of the conclusions logically follow(s) from the statements.

Statements:

B ≥ C > D

E < D ≤ F

F = G

Conclusions:

I. B > E

II. G ≥ C

III. C > E

(a) Only I and II follow (b) Only I and III follow (c) Only II and III follow (d) All three follow

Answer. D is common to the first two statements, and F links the third. Turn "E < D" round to "D > E", and the picture is:

B ≥ C > D > E, with D ≤ F = G going up from D on the other side.

I: the walk from B to E reads ≥, >, >. One way, with a strict sign. True.

III: the walk from C to E reads >, >. True.

II: G and C can only be compared through D. G = F ≥ D, and C > D. Both sit above D, so the signs change direction there, and G ≥ C is not fixed.

Once I and III were settled, only one option said "I and III" without II. So the answer is (b) Only I and III follow.

Question 3

Decide which of the assumptions is/are implicit in the statement.

Statement:

An appeal by the town council of Town M: "Please do not throw food waste into the lake. It is making the water unfit for the fish."

Assumptions:

I. Some people throw food waste into the lake.

II. An appeal can persuade at least some people to stop throwing food waste into the lake.

III. Town M has no other lake.

(a) Only I is implicit (b) All three are implicit (c) Only II and III are implicit (d) Only I and II are implicit

Answer. Use the opposite test on each part.

I: suppose nobody throws food waste into the lake. Then the appeal would be pointless, so I is implicit.

II: suppose no appeal could ever change what people do. Then the council would not bother to appeal at all. Every appeal takes for granted that it can work on at least some people, so II is implicit too.

III: suppose Town M has three other lakes. The appeal about this lake still makes complete sense, so III is a side fact, not an assumption. So the answer is (d) Only I and II are implicit.

Question 4

Decide which of the courses of action logically follow(s) for pursuing.

Statement:

The groundwater level in Village J has fallen sharply over the last five years, because many farmers pump water day and night to grow paddy.

Courses of action:

I. Farmers of Village J should be helped to switch to crops that need less water.

II. Every pump in Village J should be sealed for good.

III. A limit should be fixed on the number of hours each pump in Village J may run in a day.

(a) Only I follows (b) Only I and III follow (c) Only II and III follow (d) All three follow

Answer. II and III both act on the pumps, so put them side by side. That is the close call in this question.

III limits the pumping. It goes at the cause named in the statement, pumping day and night, and still leaves farmers water for their fields. It is practical, so it follows.

II seals every pump for good. That would end farming with pump water in the village altogether, which is out of all proportion to a falling water level. It does not follow.

I deals with the other half of the cause, the paddy that needs so much water, and helping farmers switch crops is practical. It follows. So the answer is (b) Only I and III follow.

Question 5

Identify which of the statements is/are sufficient to answer the question.

Question:

A farmer walks 5 km straight from his house to a well. At the well he turns either left or right and walks another 5 km straight to his field. In which direction is the field from his house?

Statements:

I. The farmer walked towards the north from his house to the well.

II. At the well, the farmer turned to his right.

(a) Data in statement I alone is sufficient to answer the question, while data in statement II alone is not. (b) Data in statement II alone is sufficient to answer the question, while data in statement I alone is not. (c) Data in statements I and II together are sufficient to answer the question. (d) Data in statements I and II together are not sufficient to answer the question.

Answer. A full answer here is one direction, such as north-east.

I alone: the first walk is to the north, but the turn could be left or right. The field could be north-west or north-east of the house. Not enough.

II alone: a right turn, but the first walk could have gone in any direction, so the field could lie in any of the four corner directions. Not enough.

Together, in two small steps. First, walking north and then turning right means walking east, and this step needs both statements. Second, north 5 km and then east 5 km puts the field to the north-east of the house. So the answer is (c) Data in statements I and II together are sufficient to answer the question.

Question 6

Decide which of the inferences can be drawn from the statement.

Statement:

Village D has 120 farmers. This year, 75 of them grew wheat and 60 of them grew mustard, and every farmer grew at least one of the two crops.

Inferences:

I. Exactly 15 farmers of Village D grew both wheat and mustard this year.

II. More than half the farmers of Village D grew only wheat this year.

(a) Only I can be inferred (b) Only II can be inferred (c) Both I and II can be inferred (d) Neither I nor II can be inferred

Answer. Add the two crops: 75 + 60 = 135. There are only 120 farmers, and each grew at least one crop, so the extra 15 must be farmers counted twice, that is, farmers who grew both. I is certain.

For II, take the 15 who grew both away from the 75 wheat growers. That leaves 60 who grew only wheat. Half of 120 is 60, so exactly half grew only wheat, not more than half. II is false. The trap is to stop at "75 is more than 60" and forget the farmers who grew both. So the answer is (a) Only I can be inferred.

Question 7

Decide which of the arguments is/are strong.

Question:

Should Village C build a second overhead tank to store its drinking water?

Arguments:

I. Yes, the present tank runs dry by noon every summer, and a second tank would store enough water for the whole day.

II. No, the only free land for the tank is on a slope that slides in heavy rain, so a tank built there could collapse.

(a) Only I is strong (b) Only II is strong (c) Both I and II are strong (d) Neither I nor II is strong

Answer. Judge each argument on its own, not against the other.

I is about the question, describes a real shortage and explains how a second tank would fix it. Strong.

II is also about the question and gives a concrete reason against: the only site is unsafe. Strong.

Two strong arguments on opposite sides are quite normal. They pull different ways, but each one is a sound reason, and that is all "strong" asks. So the answer is (c) Both I and II are strong.

Question 8

Decide which of the three can be possible effect/s of the cause.

Cause:

Solar street lights were put up along every lane of Village X earlier this month.

Effects:

I. Shops in Village X are staying open later in the evening this month.

II. Village X had a long power cut last summer.

III. Fewer people in Village X carry a torch when they go out after dark this month.

(a) Only I is a possible effect (b) Only I and III are possible effects (c) Only II and III are possible effects (d) All three are possible effects

Answer. Take II first, because it is the easiest to rule out. The power cut was last summer, long before the lights went up this month, so it cannot be a result of them. That strikes two options at once.

I and III both come after the lights went up and because of them. Lit lanes make it easier to keep a shop open after dark and to walk about without a torch, which is just what a sensible person would expect. So the answer is (b) Only I and III are possible effects.

Question 9

Decide which of the conclusions logically follow(s) from the statement.

Statement:

In a ploughing contest in Village N, Arjun ploughed more rows than Balu but fewer rows than Charan. Dev ploughed fewer rows than Balu, and Eknath ploughed more rows than Dev.

Conclusions:

I. Charan ploughed more rows than Dev.

II. Dev ploughed the fewest rows of the five.

III. Eknath ploughed fewer rows than Arjun.

(a) Only I follows (b) All three follow (c) Only I and II follow (d) Only II and III follow

Answer. Join the facts at Balu, then hang Eknath on Dev:

Charan > Arjun > Balu > Dev, and Eknath > Dev

I: Charan to Dev reads >, >, >. True.

II: Dev is below Balu, and so below Arjun and Charan too. Dev is also below Eknath. That covers all four others, so Dev ploughed the fewest, and the superlative is a fair copy.

III: Eknath is tied to the line only through Dev, and Eknath sits above Dev. Arjun also sits above Dev. Two people above the same person tell you nothing about each other, so III does not follow. So the answer is (c) Only I and II follow.

Question 10

Decide which of the conclusions logically follow(s) from the statements.

Statements:

R ≥ S < T

T < U

Conclusions:

I. R > U

II. R ≤ U

(a) Only I follows (b) Only II follows (c) Either I or II follows (d) Neither I nor II follows

Answer. Join at T: R ≥ S < T < U. The walk from R to U goes down to S and then up, so R and U have no fixed relation. Neither conclusion is definitely true on its own.

Now check the pair. Both are about R and U. "R > U" and "R ≤ U" between them cover every case: R is either greater than U or it is not. Whatever the real values are, one of the two conclusions is true.

This is the second kind of either-or pair, the one that comes from a walk that changes direction. Students who know only the "≥" kind mark "Neither" here. So the answer is (c) Either I or II follows.

Question 11

Decide which of the assumptions is/are implicit in the statement.

Statement:

An advertisement by Company F: "Beat the summer heat in your poultry shed. Our roof sheets keep sheds cooler on the hottest days."

Assumptions:

I. Poultry farmers want their sheds to stay cooler in summer.

II. Roof sheets made by other companies make sheds hotter.

(a) Only I is implicit (b) Only II is implicit (c) Both I and II are implicit (d) Neither I nor II is implicit

Answer. I is what the whole advertisement stands on. If poultry farmers did not mind how hot their sheds got, "beat the summer heat" would sell nothing. Turn I round and the advertisement becomes pointless, so I is implicit.

II is the trap. It sounds like something the company would be glad for you to believe, but the advertisement does not need it. Turn it round: other companies' sheets do not make sheds hotter. The claim "our sheets keep sheds cooler" still makes complete sense.

An advertisement takes for granted that buyers want what the product offers. It does not take for granted that every rival is bad. So the answer is (a) Only I is implicit.

Question 12

Decide which of the courses of action logically follow(s) for pursuing.

Statement:

A sudden hailstorm has destroyed most of the standing wheat in three villages of District H, two weeks before the harvest.

Courses of action:

I. The district administration should survey the damage so that the affected farmers can be given relief.

II. Farmers who lost their crop should be helped to get seed for the next sowing season.

(a) Only I follows (b) Only II follows (c) Both I and II follow (d) Neither I nor II follows

Answer. A course of action can deal with a problem now or stop it from hurting later, and both kinds count.

I deals with the loss now. A survey is the practical first step before any relief, and the administration can order one. It follows.

II looks ahead. Farmers who have lost a whole crop may have no money left for seed, and helping them sow again stops the loss from running into the next season. It follows too.

Neither course goes too far: there is no ban, no blanket rule, nothing out of proportion. So the answer is (c) Both I and II follow.

Question 13

Identify which of the statements is/are sufficient to answer the question.

Question:

Five farmers A, B, C, D and E sit on a long bench outside the panchayat office, all facing north. Who is seated in the middle of the bench?

Statements:

I. A sits immediately to the left of E.

II. Exactly three people sit between C and E. D sits immediately to the right of C, and B does not sit next to E.

(a) Data in statement I alone is sufficient to answer the question, while data in statement II alone is not. (b) Data in statement II alone is sufficient to answer the question, while data in statement I alone is not. (c) Data in statements I and II together are sufficient to answer the question. (d) Data in statements I and II together are not sufficient to answer the question.

Answer. Facing north, left is west and right is east. Number the seats 1 to 5 from the left.

I alone: A and E sit side by side, but the pair could be anywhere on the bench. Not enough.

II alone, step one: with exactly three people between C and E, the two of them must take the end seats, 1 and 5. Step two: D sits immediately to the right of C, and there is no seat to the right of seat 5, so C is in seat 1, D in seat 2 and E in seat 5. That leaves A and B for seats 3 and 4. B does not sit next to E, so B cannot be in seat 4. B is in seat 3, the middle.

Statement I turns out to be true as well (A in seat 4, next to E), but the question was already answered without it. Time check: two short steps in II, about 50 seconds. So the answer is (b) Data in statement II alone is sufficient to answer the question, while data in statement I alone is not.

Question 14

Decide which of the inferences can be drawn from the statement.

Statement:

In Village E, the weekly animal fair is held every Thursday, except when it rains heavily on a Thursday, in which case the fair is held on the next day. This week, Ravi bought two goats at the fair on Friday.

Inferences:

I. It rained heavily in Village E on Thursday this week.

II. This week, the fair was not held on Thursday.

III. Ravi had planned to buy the goats on Thursday.

(a) Only I and II can be inferred (b) Only II and III can be inferred (c) Only I can be inferred (d) All three can be inferred

Answer. The statement gives only one way for the fair to be held on a Friday: heavy rain on the Thursday. Ravi bought his goats at the fair on Friday, so the fair was on Friday this week, and that happens only after heavy rain on Thursday. I is certain, even though the statement never says it rained.

II follows from the same step. When the rain moves the fair to Friday, it is held on Friday in place of Thursday, so it was not held on Thursday.

III is about Ravi's plans, and the statement tells us nothing about them. He may have meant to go on Friday all along. So the answer is (a) Only I and II can be inferred.

Question 15

Decide which of the arguments is/are strong.

Question:

Should cattle be stopped from grazing inside the forest near Village R?

Arguments:

I. Yes, grazing cattle eat the young saplings, so the forest cannot grow back.

II. No, the cattle owners of Village R have no other grazing land within reach.

III. Yes, cattle are not as useful to villages as they once were.

(a) Only I is strong (b) Only II and III are strong (c) All three are strong (d) Only I and II are strong

Answer. I gives a direct, serious reason for stopping the grazing: the forest cannot renew itself. Strong.

II gives a direct, serious reason against it: the cattle would have nowhere else to graze. Strong, even though it pulls the other way.

III is about cattle in general, not about grazing in this forest, and "not as useful as they once were" is a vague opinion with nothing behind it. Weak. So the answer is (d) Only I and II are strong.

Question 16

The two statements below may be independent causes, effects of independent causes or of a common cause, or one may be the effect of the other. Decide which best describes the relation between them.

Statements:

I. The river near Village Y has changed its course and now flows two kilometres away from the village.

II. Farmers of Village Y who used to lift water straight from the river for their fields now have to lay long pipes to reach it.

(a) Statement I is the cause and statement II is its effect. (b) Statement II is the cause and statement I is its effect. (c) Both statements are independent causes. (d) Both statements are effects of a common cause.

Answer. Ask which one could bring the other about. The river moving two kilometres away explains why farmers who once took water straight from it now need long pipes. The other way round makes no sense: laying pipes cannot shift a river.

A third cause behind both does not fit either, because statement II itself says the pipes are needed "to reach it", that is, to reach the river that has moved away. II is a direct result of I. So the answer is (a) Statement I is the cause and statement II is its effect.

Question 17

Decide which of the conclusions logically follow(s) from the statement.

Statement:

In Village B, Gopal's buffalo gives no less milk than Hemant's buffalo, and Hemant's buffalo gives exactly as much milk as Ishwar's buffalo.

Conclusions:

I. Gopal's buffalo gives more milk than Ishwar's buffalo.

II. Gopal's buffalo and Ishwar's buffalo give the same amount of milk.

(a) Only I follows (b) Only II follows (c) Either I or II follows (d) Neither I nor II follows

Answer. Turn the words into signs first. "No less than" means "more than or equal to", so Gopal ≥ Hemant. "Exactly as much as" is "=", so Hemant = Ishwar. Together: Gopal ≥ Hemant = Ishwar, which gives Gopal ≥ Ishwar.

I needs ">", which is not fixed. II needs "=", which is not fixed either. But both are about Gopal's and Ishwar's buffaloes, and "more" together with "the same" is exactly "no less". One of them must be true. So the answer is (c) Either I or II follows.

Question 18

Decide which conclusion is definitely true, based on the given statements.

Statements:

K ≥ L > M

M = N < O

O ≤ P

(a) K > O (b) P > M (c) L ≥ P (d) N > K

Answer. Join the three statements at M and O: K ≥ L > M = N < O ≤ P.

Strike the walks that change direction. K to O goes down to M and up again, so K > O is not fixed. L to P turns at M in the same way, so L ≥ P goes as well.

N > K points the wrong way. N = M < L ≤ K, so N is below K, and N > K is false.

P to M, read downwards from P: P ≥ O > N = M. One way, with a strict sign. Time check: three statements but only one line to draw, about 35 seconds. So the answer is (b) P > M.

Question 19

Decide which of the assumptions is/are implicit in the statement.

Statement:

The district farm office has decided to hold soil-testing camps in every village of District T before the sowing season, so that farmers can choose the right fertiliser for their fields.

Assumptions:

I. A soil test can show which fertiliser suits a field.

II. Without a soil test, farmers do not always choose the right fertiliser.

(a) Both I and II are implicit (b) Only I is implicit (c) Only II is implicit (d) Neither I nor II is implicit

Answer. The statement gives its own purpose: so that farmers can choose the right fertiliser. Test each part against that purpose.

I: suppose a soil test could not show which fertiliser suits a field. Then the camps could not serve their purpose, so I is implicit.

II: suppose farmers already chose the right fertiliser every time, test or no test. Then the camps would add nothing, and there would be no reason to hold them. So II is implicit too. It is not a complaint about farmers, only the gap that the plan is meant to fill. So the answer is (a) Both I and II are implicit.

Question 20

Decide which of the courses of action logically follow(s) for pursuing.

Statement:

Several young trees planted along the canal in Village L have been cut down at night by people nobody has seen.

Courses of action:

I. The village council should fine every family living near the canal.

II. The village council should ask the police to find out who cut the trees.

(a) Only I follows (b) Only II follows (c) Both I and II follow (d) Neither I nor II follows

Answer. I punishes every family near the canal, though nobody knows who cut the trees. Most of those families had nothing to do with it, so I is out of proportion and does not follow.

II goes after the people who did it, and asking the police is well within the council's power. It follows.

This pair has the usual shape of a close call: one action aims at whoever is at fault, the other at everyone who happens to be nearby. So the answer is (b) Only II follows.

Question 21

Identify which of the statements is/are sufficient to answer the question.

Question:

How is P related to S?

Statements:

I. P is the son of Q, and Q is the sister of R.

II. R is the father of S.

(a) Data in statement I alone is sufficient to answer the question, while data in statement II alone is not. (b) Data in statement II alone is sufficient to answer the question, while data in statement I alone is not. (c) Data in statements I and II together are sufficient to answer the question. (d) Data in statements I and II together are not sufficient to answer the question.

Answer. I alone never mentions S, and II alone never mentions P. Neither can settle the relation on its own, so the first two options go.

Together, walk from P: P's mother is Q, Q's brother is R (II calls R a father, so R is a man), and R's child is S. So S's father is the brother of P's mother. P and S are children of a brother and a sister, which makes them cousins. The word cousin is the same for a boy and a girl, so S's gender does not matter. So the answer is (c) Data in statements I and II together are sufficient to answer the question.

Question 22

Decide which of the inferences can be drawn from the statement.

Statement:

The rain gauge in Village F recorded 40 mm of rain on Monday and none on Tuesday. The gauge in Village G, 5 km away, recorded 15 mm on each of the two days.

Inferences:

I. Village G gets more rain than Village F in most weeks.

II. Over these two days, the gauge in Village F recorded more rain than the gauge in Village G.

(a) Only I can be inferred (b) Both I and II can be inferred (c) Only II can be inferred (d) Neither I nor II can be inferred

Answer. Add up each village. F: 40 + 0 = 40 mm. G: 15 + 15 = 30 mm. Over the two days F recorded 10 mm more, so II is certain.

I talks about most weeks, and the statement covers just two days. G got more rain on Tuesday, but one day says nothing about most weeks, and over these two days F actually got more. I cannot be inferred. So the answer is (c) Only II can be inferred.

Question 23

Read the statement and the arguments, and select the appropriate answer.

Statement:

Building a check dam on the stream near Village S will raise the water level in the village wells.

Arguments:

I. Water held behind a check dam soaks into the ground only where the soil is loose, and the stream bed near Village S is solid rock.

II. The wells of Village S draw their water from a deep layer that the stream does not feed.

(a) I strengthens while II weakens the statement (b) II strengthens while I weakens the statement (c) Both I and II strengthen the statement (d) Both I and II weaken the statement

Answer. A check dam can raise well water only if two things happen: water soaks down from behind the dam, and it reaches the layer that the wells draw from.

I breaks the first link. On solid rock the stored water cannot soak down, so the wells gain nothing. I weakens the claim.

II breaks the second link. Even water that did soak down would not reach a layer the stream does not feed. II weakens the claim too.

Both arguments sound calm and technical, which is why it is easy to mark one of them as a strengthener without checking. So the answer is (d) Both I and II weaken the statement.

Question 24

Decide which of the two reasons can explain the event in the statement.

Statement:

This winter, far fewer migratory birds came to the lake near Village Z than in earlier winters.

Reasons:

I. Most of the lake was dry this winter because the rains had failed.

II. A new boating club ran noisy motorboats on the lake from morning to evening all winter.

(a) Only I is a possible reason (b) Only II is a possible reason (c) Both I and II are possible reasons (d) Neither I nor II is a possible reason

Answer. A reason counts if it could plausibly bring about what was seen.

I: birds that come to a lake need water, and a mostly dry lake offers little of it. That would keep many birds away. Possible.

II: noisy boats all day disturb birds that come to rest and feed. That too would keep many away. Possible.

The two reasons do not have to compete. Either one alone, or both together, could explain why fewer birds came. So the answer is (c) Both I and II are possible reasons.

Question 25

Decide which of the conclusions logically follow(s) from the statement.

Statement:

Every fishing boat of Village Q is tied up at the jetty whenever it is not out at sea. Since yesterday's storm warning, none of these boats has been out at sea.

Conclusions:

I. At present, every fishing boat of Village Q is tied up at the jetty.

II. The storm will reach Village Q before the end of today.

(a) Only I follows (b) Only II follows (c) Both I and II follow (d) Neither I nor II follows

Answer. Link the two sentences. A boat that is not out at sea is tied up at the jetty. Since yesterday, no boat has been out at sea. So right now, every boat is tied up at the jetty. I uses "every", but the statement used "every" first, so the strong word is a fair copy here. I follows.

II is a forecast. A warning says a storm may come, not when it will arrive, and nothing in the statement fixes "before the end of today". II does not follow. So the answer is (a) Only I follows.

Question 26

A statement is followed by four conclusions. Decide which of the conclusions is/are true based on the given statement.

Statement:

D > E ≥ F = G ≤ H < J

Conclusions:

I. D > G

II. J > F

III. E ≥ H

IV. D = F

(a) Only conclusions I and II are true (b) Only conclusions II and IV are true (c) Only conclusion I is true (d) Conclusions I, II and III are true

Answer. The chain is already in one line, so go straight to the walks.

I: D to G reads >, ≥, =. One way, with a strict sign. True.

II: read downwards from J: J > H ≥ G = F. One way, with a strict sign. True.

III: E to H goes down to F and G and then up to H. The direction changes, so E ≥ H is not fixed.

IV: the walk from D to F has a strict sign, so D > F, and D = F is false.

Only one option names exactly I and II. So the answer is (a) Only conclusions I and II are true.

Question 27

Decide which of the assumptions is/are implicit in the statement.

Statement:

Notice at the gate of the bird sanctuary near Village W: "Visitors are requested to keep their voices low between 6 a.m. and 9 a.m."

Assumptions:

I. Most visitors to the sanctuary talk loudly.

II. The birds in the sanctuary are quieter after 9 a.m.

(a) Only I is implicit (b) Only II is implicit (c) Both I and II are implicit (d) Neither I nor II is implicit

Answer. Both parts sound close to the notice, so test them with care.

I: suppose most visitors already speak softly. The request still makes sense, because it needs only some visitors to be loud now and then. "Most" asks for more than the notice needs, so I is not implicit.

II: suppose the birds are just as noisy after 9 a.m. The notice is unaffected, since it never says why the hours are 6 to 9. II is a guess about the birds, not something the notice depends on. So the answer is (d) Neither I nor II is implicit.

Question 28

Decide which of the courses of action logically follow(s) for pursuing.

Statement:

Thick fog every morning this month has delayed the vans that carry milk from the villages to the dairy plant in Town V.

Courses of action:

I. The dairy plant should keep its milk-receiving counter open for longer each morning this month.

II. The dairy plant should be moved to a place where there is no fog.

(a) Only I follows (b) Only II follows (c) Both I and II follow (d) Neither I nor II follows

Answer. I accepts that the vans will be late this month and makes room for them. It is simple, it deals with the problem stated, and the plant can decide it by itself. It follows.

II sounds like a fix, but moving a whole dairy plant because of a foggy month is not practical, and no one can promise a place without fog. It is closer to a wish than a course of action. So the answer is (a) Only I follows.

Question 29

Identify which of the statements is/are sufficient to answer the question.

Question:

How is K related to J?

Statements:

I. K is a grandchild of L.

II. L is the father of J.

(a) Data in statement I alone is sufficient to answer the question, while data in statement II alone is not. (b) Data in statement II alone is sufficient to answer the question, while data in statement I alone is not. (c) Data in statements I and II together are sufficient to answer the question. (d) Data in statements I and II together are not sufficient to answer the question.

Answer. I alone says nothing about J, and II alone says nothing about K, so neither works alone.

Together, K's parent is a child of L, and J is a child of L. But L may have more than one child. If K's parent is J, then K is J's son or daughter. If K's parent is J's brother or sister, then K is J's nephew or niece. The statements do not say which, and K's gender is open as well.

This is the two-step trap: the line from K up to L and the line from L down to J meet, but they can meet at J or at J's brother or sister. So the answer is (d) Data in statements I and II together are not sufficient to answer the question.

Question 30

Decide which of the inferences can be drawn from the statement.

Statement:

Since piped water reached every house in Village U in March, the water tanker that used to sell drinking water in the village has had almost no customers. Its owner has now put the tanker up for sale.

Inferences:

I. Piped water was brought to Village U because the tanker's water was unclean.

II. The owner of the tanker has found a buyer for it.

(a) Only I can be inferred (b) Only II can be inferred (c) Both I and II can be inferred (d) Neither I nor II can be inferred

Answer. I gives a reason for bringing piped water. The statement never says why it was brought, and nothing in it suggests the tanker's water was unclean. Not inferable.

II is the closer trap. "Put up for sale" means the owner is looking for a buyer, not that one has been found. The sale may never happen. Not inferable. So the answer is (d) Neither I nor II can be inferred.

Question 31

Decide which of the arguments is/are strong.

Question:

Should the council of Village G close the weekly cattle market?

Arguments:

I. Yes, other villages have closed their cattle markets.

II. No, many families in Village G earn their living by buying and selling cattle at the market.

(a) Only I is strong (b) Only II is strong (c) Both I and II are strong (d) Neither I nor II is strong

Answer. I says only that others have done it. It gives no reason that applies to Village G, and copying others is not an argument. Weak.

II points to a real and serious loss: families would lose their living. It is directly about the question. Strong. So the answer is (b) Only II is strong.

Question 32

Decide which of the three can be possible effect/s of the cause.

Cause:

The town council of Town A has started charging a fee to every household that does not separate its wet and dry waste.

Effects:

I. More households in Town A have begun keeping wet and dry waste in separate bins.

II. Several households in Town A have complained to the council about the fee.

III. The town council has repaired the street lights of Town A.

(a) Only I is a possible effect (b) Only II and III are possible effects (c) Only I and II are possible effects (d) All three are possible effects

Answer. I is the result the fee is meant to bring: people separate their waste to avoid paying. Possible effect.

II is a result too, even though the council would not want it. A new fee often draws complaints, and an effect does not have to be a welcome one.

III happens in the same town and is done by the same council, but nothing links street lights to a waste fee. Sharing a town is not the same as being caused. So the answer is (c) Only I and II are possible effects.