A 15-Minute Plan for This Chapter
The Reasoning section gives you 25 questions and its own locked 15-minute clock. That is 36 seconds a question on average. A right answer earns 2 marks and a wrong one costs 0.5.
Questions from this chapter do not all take the same time. A plain substitution is quick. A fill-the-signs question, where four sign orders have to be tried, is not. So give each kind its own budget instead of treating them all alike.
Time targets
| Type | Target time |
|---|---|
| Symbol substitution | about 30–40 seconds |
| Sign interchange or number interchange | about 40–50 seconds |
| Filling signs or correct equation | about 45–60 seconds |
| Symbol rule or coded inequality | about 30–45 seconds |
A question that swaps two signs and two numbers at once is still an interchange question. It has two swaps to apply, though, so expect it to sit at the top of the interchange range.
Reading the type from the first line
You save time before any working starts if you know the type from the first few words.
- "What will come in place of the question mark (?)…" or "what is the value of…" with meanings or swaps given: substitution. Rewrite and work it.
- "Which two signs…", "Which two numbers…": interchange. The options carry the work.
- "Select the correct combination of mathematical signs…": filling signs. Again the options carry the work.
- "By interchanging the given two signs, which of the following equations…": correct equation. Each option is a full equation to test.
- "If 4 @ 3 = …": symbol rule. "Statements… Conclusions…": coded inequality.
Time for each type
In substitution the time goes on careful rewriting, and that is time well spent. In the option types it goes on working all four options in full, and most of that is wasted. The checks in this section knock out two or three options before you finish a single sum. Use them every time, and an interchange question fits inside 50 seconds with room to spare.
Time saved on the quick types goes to the slow ones. A substitution done in 30 seconds puts a few seconds in hand for a fill question later in the section.
Rewrite First, Then Work
Most slips in substitution questions happen because the student tries to change the signs and do the arithmetic in one go. Halfway through, the eye goes back to the printed line and picks up a sign that should have changed.
The habit
On your rough sheet, copy the expression again with the new signs, one sign at a time. Do not work out anything while you copy. Only when the new line is complete do you start the sum. The two jobs stay apart, and neither spoils the other.
For example: '+' means '×', '−' means '+', '×' means '÷' and '÷' means '−'. The line 56 + 3 − 36 × 4 ÷ 9 is rewritten as 56 × 3 + 36 ÷ 4 − 9. Now it is an ordinary sum: 168 + 9 − 9 = 168.
Which way the meaning runs
"'+' means '×'" tells you what to do when you see +. You see +, you do ×. If you read it the other way round, you turn every × into +, and you get a different answer. That answer is usually sitting in the options, so a wrong reading never warns you.
When the question says two signs are interchanged, direction does not matter. + becomes × and × becomes +, both ways at once.
Letters and symbols for signs
Some questions write letters or symbols where the signs should be: "A means '÷'", "'@' stands for 'addition'". The habit is the same. Write the real signs in first, and only then start working.
Brackets stay where they are
If the expression has brackets, copy them exactly. Only the signs change, inside and outside the brackets. The brackets are still worked first.
[SSC Tip] Write the new line directly under the printed one, sign under sign. A missed sign then shows up with one glance up and down.
Find Where × and ÷ Act
Once the line is rewritten, it has to be worked in BODMAS order. Brackets first. Then × and ÷, from left to right. Then + and −, from left to right.
Split the line into pieces
Before you calculate, look at where the + and − signs sit. They cut the line into pieces. Each piece is either a single number or a run of × and ÷.
For example: 65 − 36 ÷ 4 × 3 + 16 ÷ 8 has three pieces: 65, then 36 ÷ 4 × 3, then 16 ÷ 8. Work each piece on its own: 65, 27 and 2. Then join them from left to right: 65 − 27 + 2 = 40.
Some students draw a light bracket round each run of × and ÷ on the rough sheet. It takes two seconds and makes the order of work plain to see.
Inside a piece
Inside a run of × and ÷, go from left to right. 36 ÷ 4 × 3 is 9 × 3 = 27. Doing the division first is also safe, because it gives the same result as working left to right.
Between the pieces
- and − are also worked from left to right. 65 − 27 + 2 means take 27 from 65 and then add 2, which gives 40. It does not mean 65 − 29. If you add 27 and 2 first, you get 36, and that wrong number is a favourite among the options.
When the sum goes strange
Working the whole line from left to right, as printed, is the other common slip. Here it would give 65 − 36 = 29, and then 29 ÷ 4, which is not a whole number. A remainder half-way through a substitution is a warning. The questions are set so that the right working stays in whole numbers, so stop and check your order of work.
Use the Options
In interchange, fill and correct-equation questions, the answer is one of four options, and each option is a different equation to test. Working all four in full is the slow way. These checks throw out most of them first.
Odd or even, and the last digit
Look at the right side. If it is odd, any option whose left side comes out even is gone. You can usually tell odd or even from the pieces without finishing the sum.
One fact saves a lot of time here. Swapping + and − never changes odd or even, because a + b and a − b are always both odd or both even. So if the printed left side is even and the right side is odd, "+ and −" cannot be the answer.
The units digit is a sharper test. Work only with the last digits of the pieces. For example: 95 − 24 + 3 has units 5 − 4 + 3, which ends in 4. If the right side ends in 7, this option is out.
Rough size of the left side
Guess the size of each option before you work it. A product of two two-digit numbers runs into the hundreds. A string of small numbers joined by + and − stays small. If the right side is 23 and an option starts with 96 × 8 = 768, only a big division straight after it could bring it down, so test it last. If the right side is 398 and an option leaves only small pieces, it cannot be right either.
A division with a remainder
These questions are built so that the right option works in whole numbers. If working an option in BODMAS order runs into a division like 26 ÷ 4, it is almost never the answer. Set it aside and test the others first.
Test the option that changes the biggest piece first
The biggest piece on the left decides most of the value. Compare the right side with the left side as printed. If they are far apart, the answer must change the biggest piece, so test the options that touch it first. If they are close, the answer makes a small change, and the options that break up the big piece can wait.
Watch for swaps that change nothing at all. Swapping two numbers that form a product on their own (6 × 8 becomes 8 × 6, with no other × or ÷ joined to them) leaves the value the same. So does swapping two numbers that are both simply added, like the 9 and 4 in 56 + 9 + 4. If the printed equation is false, such an option is out at sight.
[SSC Tip] These checks only remove options. Before you mark the one that is left, work it in full. It takes ten seconds and catches a slip in the checks themselves.
Values of (I) and (II): One Equation First
One form gives a swap of two signs and two numbers, then two expressions, and asks for the values of both after the swap. The options are pairs, like "44, 54".
Pick the column that splits the options
Do not work both expressions straight away. Read the options first. Look down the first values, then down the second values. Choose the column where the four numbers differ most, and work that expression alone.
For example: the options are 41, 18 and 41, 26 and 37, 30 and 41, 22. The first values are 41, 41, 37 and 41, so working (I) would remove only one option. The second values are 18, 26, 30 and 22, all different. Work (II) alone, and only one option will have your value.
If your value matches two options, work the other expression to choose between them.
Apply both swaps, everywhere
In each expression, swap the two numbers wherever they appear, and swap the two signs wherever they appear. The order of the two swaps does not matter. Doing both does. A favourite wrong option comes from doing only the sign swap or only the number swap, so a value that matches one of those is not proof of anything.
After the swaps, the usual rules apply: × and ÷ from left to right, then + and − from left to right.
Not correct and correct
The same swap line is also used with two equations and the question "which of the following equations will be not correct?". Here both equations must be checked, since the options are "Only I", "Only II", "Both" and "Neither". A quick check still helps: if one equation clearly holds after the swap, two options go at once.
Symbol Rules: Try the Simple Families First
When the rule is given
"If a @ b means a² − b + 4, find 7 @ 3." Put the numbers in and work it: 49 − 3 + 4 = 50. Keep a and b in their places. 7 @ 3 and 3 @ 7 are usually different.
When only examples are given
Now you have to find the rule. Do not try rules at random. Go through the families in order, from the simplest:
- Add or subtract: a + b, a − b, perhaps with a fixed number added.
- Multiply: a × b, then a × b with a, b or a + b added or taken away.
- Squares: a² + b², a² − b², (a + b)², a² + b, a² − b.
- Joining: the answer is two numbers written side by side, such as a + b followed by a − b.
Test the first example against each family. When a family comes close, look at what is left over. If the leftover is a, b or their sum, you probably have the rule. Then test the rule on every other example before you use it on the target.
For example: 5 # 3 = 20 and 7 # 2 = 21. Adding gives 8 and 9, far too small. Multiplying gives 15 and 14. The leftovers are 5 and 7, which are the first numbers each time. So the rule is a × b + a, and the second example agrees: 7 × 2 + 7 = 21.
Signs of a joining rule
If the answer fits none of the families above, such as 82 from 5 and 3, read it as two numbers side by side. Here 8 = 5 + 3 and 2 = 5 − 3.
One example is not enough
A rule that fits one example is only a guess. Two different rules can fit the first example and split on the second. That is why the questions give two or three. The wrong options are often the values that a half-tested rule gives for the target.
Coded Inequalities: Decode, Then Chain
These questions give each symbol a meaning, such as "'P @ Q' means 'P is greater than Q'". Then come statements written in the symbols, and conclusions to test.
Step 1: Decode every statement
Rewrite each statement with the real signs >, < and =. Do it on paper. Holding three made-up symbols in your head while you reason is where the time goes.
Step 2: Join them into one chain
Statements share letters. Join them through those letters into one line. For example, A < B, B = C and C > D become A < B = C > D. If a statement is written the other way round, flip it before you join it. "D < C" and "C > D" say the same thing.
Step 3: Walk along the chain
A conclusion is true only if you can walk from one letter to the other through signs that all point the same way. An = sign does not break the walk. In A < B = C > D, A < C is true, because the walk from A to C passes through < and =. But A and D are not linked: the walk passes through < and then >, which point opposite ways. Nothing is certain about A and D.
When "either" is the answer
Some questions use a meaning like "P is greater than or equal to Q". Suppose the chain gives only K ≥ M. Then "K > M" is not certain, and "K = M" is not certain, but one of the two must be true. If the two conclusions are exactly that pair, the answer is "Either I or II".
Check two things before you choose "either". Both conclusions must be about the same two letters, and between them they must cover every case the chain allows. If the chain allows K < M as well, then "either" is wrong too.
Write the chain once, cleanly, and test both conclusions against that same line. Decoding again for the second conclusion wastes the time you saved.
When to Skip and Come Back
Every question carries the same 2 marks, so no single question is worth a minute and a half. Some rules for this chapter:
When to skip
- a substitution answer is not in the options after one careful rewrite and working
- an interchange or fill question still has two options alive after the checks, and a full minute has gone
- a symbol rule fits the first example, fails on the second, and the next family does not help
- a coded inequality has a long chain and you have not finished decoding it within the 30–45 seconds you planned
Guessing between two
If your checks have cut the options down to two, a guess is worth taking. Half the time you gain 2 marks and half the time you lose 0.5, which averages 0.75 a question. A blind guess with all four options alive averages only 0.125, and the time is better spent on a question you can solve.
Coming back
A skipped substitution often comes out at once on a second try, because the slip was in the rewrite and a fresh rewrite does not repeat it. Write the new line again from the printed question. Do not work from your old rough line, which still has the slip in it.
For interchange questions, start again from the options you had not yet struck out. Your earlier checks still hold, so there is no need to repeat them.
Keep track
Put a small mark in the question palette or on your rough sheet against every skipped question, with the options you had left. When you return with three minutes to go, you want to pick up exactly where you stopped.
Solved Questions
Question 1
If '+' means '÷', '−' means '×', '×' means '+' and '÷' means '−', what will come in place of the question mark (?) in the following equation?
56 ÷ 24 + 8 × 7 − 4 = ?
(a) 44 (b) 25 (c) 81 (d) 56
Answer. Do not work anything yet. Write the new line under the old one, one sign at a time. Where you see ÷, write −. Where you see +, write ÷. Where you see ×, write +. Where you see −, write ×.
56 ÷ 24 + 8 × 7 − 4 becomes 56 − 24 ÷ 8 + 7 × 4.
Now it is a plain sum. Division and multiplication first: 24 ÷ 8 = 3 and 7 × 4 = 28. Then left to right: 56 − 3 + 28 = 81.
If you go strictly left to right you get 44, and if you add 3 and 28 before taking away you get 25. Both are in the options. So the answer is (c) 81.
Question 2
What will come in place of the question mark (?) in the following equation, if '+' and '−' are interchanged and '×' and '÷' are interchanged?
65 ÷ 5 − 84 × 12 + 9 ÷ 3 = ?
(a) 305 (b) 345 (c) 291 (d) 1018
Answer. Rewrite first. Every + becomes −, every − becomes +, every × becomes ÷ and every ÷ becomes ×.
65 ÷ 5 − 84 × 12 + 9 ÷ 3 becomes 65 × 5 + 84 ÷ 12 − 9 × 3.
Now find where × and ÷ act. The + and − signs cut the line into three pieces: 65 × 5, then 84 ÷ 12, then 9 × 3. Work each piece on its own: 325, 7 and 27. What is left is 325 + 7 − 27 = 305.
If you swap × and ÷ but forget to swap + and −, the line reads 65 × 5 − 84 ÷ 12 + 9 × 3 = 345. So the answer is (a) 305.
Question 3
If P means '×', Q means '−', R means '+' and S means '÷', what will come in place of the question mark (?) in the following equation?
75 S 5 P 4 Q 36 S 9 R 8 = ?
(a) 48 (b) 72 (c) 56 (d) 64
Answer. Letters in place of signs need the same habit. Put the real signs in first: S is ÷, P is ×, Q is − and R is +.
75 S 5 P 4 Q 36 S 9 R 8 becomes 75 ÷ 5 × 4 − 36 ÷ 9 + 8.
The pieces with × and ÷ are 75 ÷ 5 × 4 and 36 ÷ 9. Work the first from left to right: 75 ÷ 5 = 15, and 15 × 4 = 60. The second is 36 ÷ 9 = 4. Now 60 − 4 + 8 = 64.
Take care with that last step. − and + are worked from left to right, so it is 56 + 8, not 60 − 12. The slip gives 48. So the answer is (d) 64.
Question 4
Which two signs should be interchanged to make the given equation correct?
85 − 6 × 3 + 18 ÷ 2 = 119
(a) + and − (b) − and × (c) ÷ and × (d) + and ×
Answer. The right side, 119, is odd. Use that before doing any full sum.
Start with (a). Swapping + and − never changes odd or even. The printed left side is 85 − 18 + 9 = 76, which is even, so after this swap it is still even. It cannot be 119. Out.
(b) gives 85 × 6 − 3 + 18 ÷ 2 = 510 − 3 + 9. Even, take away odd, add odd: the result is even. Strike it out.
(d) gives 85 − 6 + 3 × 18 ÷ 2 = 85 − 6 + 27. Odd, take away even, add odd: even again. Out.
Only (c) is left, so check it in full: 85 − 6 ÷ 3 + 18 × 2 = 85 − 2 + 36 = 119. It balances. So the answer is (c) ÷ and ×.
Question 5
Which two signs should be interchanged to make the given equation correct?
76 − 12 ÷ 4 × 5 + 9 = 118
(a) + and ÷ (b) × and ÷ (c) − and × (d) + and ×
Answer. Look at what each swap does to the division before you work anything.
(a) + and ÷ turns the end of the line into 4 × 5 ÷ 9, which is 20 ÷ 9. That leaves a remainder, so it cannot be the answer.
(b) × and ÷ gives 12 × 4 ÷ 5, which is 48 ÷ 5. Same problem. Not this one.
Two are left. (c) − and × puts 76 × 12 ÷ 4 at the front, and that piece alone is 228. The right side is only 118, so that is out on size. (d) + and × gives 76 − 12 ÷ 4 + 5 × 9 = 76 − 3 + 45 = 118. It balances.
Time check: two options fell without any working, so this sits well inside the 40–50 seconds for an interchange question. So the answer is (d) + and ×.
Question 6
Which two numbers (not digits) should be interchanged to make the given equation correct?
65 + 7 × 9 − 48 ÷ 3 = 398
(a) 7 and 9 (b) 9 and 48 (c) 7 and 48 (d) 65 and 3
Answer. Size things up first. As printed, the left side is 65 + 63 − 16 = 112. The right side, 398, is far bigger. The only piece that can grow that much is the product 7 × 9, so the swap has to put a big number into it.
(a) just turns 7 × 9 into 9 × 7. Nothing changes, so the left side stays 112. That fails.
(d) leaves 7 × 9 alone and puts 65 under the division sign. The left side gets smaller, not bigger. Out.
That leaves the two options that bring 48 into the product. Try (b): 65 + 7 × 48 − 9 ÷ 3 = 65 + 336 − 3 = 398. It balances. For completeness, (c) gives 65 + 48 × 9 − 7 ÷ 3, and 7 ÷ 3 leaves a remainder. So the answer is (b) 9 and 48.
Question 7
Which two numbers (not digits) should be interchanged to make the given equation correct?
95 − 6 × 8 + 24 ÷ 4 = 74
(a) 6 and 8 (b) 24 and 4 (c) 8 and 4 (d) 6 and 4
Answer. (a) swaps two numbers that are multiplied together. 6 × 8 and 8 × 6 are the same, so the left side does not move. As printed it is 95 − 48 + 6 = 53, not 74. Cross it off.
(b) turns 24 ÷ 4 into 4 ÷ 24, which is not a whole number. Out.
Between (c) and (d), the units digit is enough. (c) gives 95 − 6 × 4 + 24 ÷ 8 = 95 − 24 + 3. Using units only: 5 − 4 = 1, and 1 + 3 = 4. That matches the 4 of 74. (d) gives 95 − 4 × 8 + 24 ÷ 6 = 95 − 32 + 4, and the units run 5 − 2 = 3, then 3 + 4 = 7. Strike it out.
A full check of (c): 95 − 24 + 3 = 74. So the answer is (c) 8 and 4.
Question 8
Which two signs and two numbers should be interchanged to make the following equation correct?
56 × 3 − 72 ÷ 8 + 4 = 55
(a) 8 and 4, + and − (b) 56 and 72, + and × (c) 3 and 4, + and − (d) 56 and 72, − and ×
Answer. The biggest piece on the left is 56 × 3 = 168, and the right side is only 55. So test first the options that break up that product.
(a) keeps 56 × 3 at the front and only moves numbers in the small pieces. The left side stays well above 150. (c) makes the front 56 × 4, which is bigger still. Both out on size.
(b) and (d) both swap 56 and 72, which breaks up the product. Test (d). The numbers give 72 × 3 − 56 ÷ 8 + 4. Then − and × change places: 72 − 3 × 56 ÷ 8 + 4. Work × and ÷ from left to right: 3 × 56 = 168, and 168 ÷ 8 = 21. Then 72 − 21 + 4 = 55. It balances.
(b) gives 72 + 3 − 56 ÷ 8 × 4 = 72 + 3 − 28 = 47, so it fails. So the answer is (d) 56 and 72, − and ×.
Question 9
After interchanging the given two numbers and two signs, what will be the values of equations (I) and (II) respectively?
- and ×, 2 and 5
I. 36 × 5 + 2 − 14 ÷ 7
II. 26 + 5 × 4 − 10 ÷ 2
(a) 44, 32 (b) 44, 54 (c) 75, 51 (d) 44, 129
Answer. Read the options before you start. Three of them give 44 for (I), so working (I) first would remove only one option. The values for (II) are 32, 54, 51 and 129, all different. So work (II) alone.
II. 26 + 5 × 4 − 10 ÷ 2. Swap the numbers 2 and 5: 26 + 2 × 4 − 10 ÷ 5. Now swap + and ×: 26 × 2 + 4 − 10 ÷ 5. BODMAS gives 52 + 4 − 2 = 54.
Only one option has 54 for (II). If you have a few seconds spare, (I) confirms it: after both swaps it reads 36 + 2 × 5 − 14 ÷ 7 = 36 + 10 − 2 = 44. So the answer is (b) 44, 54.
Question 10
By interchanging the given two signs, which of the following equations will be correct?
− and ÷
(a) 45 ÷ 14 − 7 × 2 + 9 = 52 (b) 65 ÷ 45 − 9 × 3 + 8 = 58 (c) 35 − 5 × 2 ÷ 7 + 6 = 20 (d) 85 ÷ 15 − 5 × 4 + 6 = 254
Answer. Swap − and ÷ in each option and size it up before working it fully.
(d) becomes 85 − 15 ÷ 5 × 4 + 6. Nothing in it multiplies up to a big number, so the left side stays below 100, nowhere near 254. Out.
(c) becomes 35 ÷ 5 × 2 − 7 + 6 = 14 − 7 + 6 = 13. Not 20. Not this one.
(a) becomes 45 − 14 ÷ 7 × 2 + 9. Work 14 ÷ 7 × 2 from left to right: 2 × 2 = 4. Then 45 − 4 + 9 = 50, not 52. That fails.
(b) becomes 65 − 45 ÷ 9 × 3 + 8 = 65 − 15 + 8 = 58. It holds. So the answer is (b) 65 ÷ 45 − 9 × 3 + 8 = 58.
Question 11
Select the correct combination of mathematical signs to sequentially replace the * signs and to balance the given equation.
136 * 8 * 4 * 3 * 5 = 28
(a) ÷, −, +, × (b) ×, ÷, +, − (c) −, ÷, ×, + (d) ÷, +, ×, −
Answer. The right side is 28, and the first number is 136. Unless 136 is divided early, the left side cannot come down that far.
(b) starts 136 × 8, which is 1088. Even after ÷ 4 it is 272. Far too big. Out.
(c) starts 136 − and takes away only 8 ÷ 4 × 3 = 6, then adds 5. That is 135. Cross it off.
Both (a) and (d) start with 136 ÷ 8 = 17, so work those two. (a): 17 − 4 + 3 × 5 = 17 − 4 + 15 = 28. It balances. (d): 17 + 4 × 3 − 5 = 17 + 12 − 5 = 24. So the answer is (a) ÷, −, +, ×.
Question 12
Select the correct combination of mathematical signs to sequentially replace the * signs and to balance the given equation.
56 * 8 * 6 * 9 * 65 * 14
(a) ÷, +, ×, −, = (b) ×, ÷, +, =, − (c) ÷, ×, +, =, − (d) ÷, ×, =, +, −
Answer. Here '=' is one of the signs, so each option splits the numbers in a different place. Find the '=' in each option and work the shorter side first.
(a) puts '=' last, so its right side is just 14. The left side is 56 ÷ 8 + 6 × 9 − 65 = 7 + 54 − 65 = −4. Out.
(d) puts '=' after 6. The left side is 56 ÷ 8 × 6 = 42, and the right side is 9 + 65 − 14 = 60. Strike it out.
(b) and (c) both put '=' after 9, so both right sides are 65 − 14 = 51. Now the left sides. (b) starts 56 × 8 ÷ 6, and 448 ÷ 6 leaves a remainder. Out. (c) gives 56 ÷ 8 × 6 + 9 = 42 + 9 = 51. Both sides are 51. So the answer is (c) ÷, ×, +, =, −.
Question 13
If 4 # 3 = 19 and 8 # 6 = 62, then what is the value of 7 # 9?
(a) 79 (b) 70 (c) 63 (d) 72
Answer. Try the simple families in order. Adding gives 4 + 3 = 7, far too small. Multiplying gives 4 × 3 = 12, which is 7 short of 19. And 7 is just 4 + 3. So the rule may be a × b + a + b.
Test it on the second example before you trust it: 8 × 6 + 8 + 6 = 48 + 14 = 62. It fits.
Now 7 # 9 = 7 × 9 + 7 + 9 = 63 + 16 = 79. Adding a fixed 7 to the product, as the first example seems to suggest, gives 70, which is a trap. So the answer is (a) 79.
Question 14
In the following question, 'P © Q' means 'P is greater than Q', 'P & Q' means 'P is less than Q' and 'P % Q' means 'P is equal to Q'.
Statements: M & K, K % N, N © R
Conclusions: I. N © M II. R & M
(a) Both follow (b) Only I follows (c) Only II follows (d) Neither I nor II follows
Answer. Decode the statements into plain signs first, then join them into one chain. M & K means M < K. K % N means K = N. N © R means N > R. Together: M < K = N > R.
Conclusion I says N > M. Walk along the chain from M: M < K and K = N, so M < N, which is the same as N > M. True.
Conclusion II says R < M. R and M both sit below N, but nothing links them to each other. R could be bigger or smaller than M, so this is not certain.
So the answer is (b) Only I follows.