Symbol Rules Given in the Question

In this type a new sign is made up for the question, and its rule is printed with it:

"If a # b means 2a + b − 3, what is the value of 14 # 5?"

The letters in the rule only mark places. a stands for the number written before the sign, and b for the number written after it. So in 14 # 5, a is 14 and b is 5.

The method

  1. Copy the rule.
  2. Put the first number in place of a and the second in place of b.
  3. Work it out with BODMAS.

For 14 # 5: 2 × 14 + 5 − 3 = 28 + 5 − 3 = 30.

Three slips to avoid

  • Order. 5 # 14 is a different question. It gives 2 × 5 + 14 − 3 = 21. The first number always goes into a.
  • Squares. a² means a × a. So 7² is 49, not 14.
  • Brackets in the rule. If the rule says a × b − (a + b), work out a + b first and take the whole of it away.

Two symbols in one expression

Some questions define two symbols and then join them, like this:

"If a % b = a + b + 1 and a & b = a × b, find (3 % 4) & 2."

Work the bracket first. 3 % 4 = 3 + 4 + 1 = 8. Now the expression is 8 & 2, and that is 8 × 2 = 16.

The result of the bracket takes the place where the bracket stood. In (3 % 4) & 2 the bracket is first, so its result is a. In 3 % (4 & 2) the bracket is second: 4 & 2 = 8, and then 3 % 8 = 3 + 8 + 1 = 12, which is b's place. The same numbers in a different bracket give a different answer, so read the brackets carefully.

How long it should take

A rule given in the question is the quickest kind in this chapter. Aim for 30 to 45 seconds, and less when the rule is short.

Solved Questions

Question 1

If a @ b means a² + b − 1, what is the value of 7 @ 4?

(a) 53 (b) 22 (c) 52 (d) 17

Answer. Here a is the first number, 7, and b is the second, 4. Put them into the rule: 7² + 4 − 1 = 49 + 4 − 1 = 52.

The wrong options come from the usual slips. Taking the numbers the other way round gives 4² + 7 − 1 = 22. Reading 7² as 7 × 2 gives 14 + 4 − 1 = 17. So the answer is (c) 52.

Question 2

If p # q = 3p − 2q, what is the value of 4 # 9?

(a) 19 (b) −6 (c) 6 (d) 30

Answer. p is the first number and q is the second, so p = 4 and q = 9. Then 3p = 12 and 2q = 18, and 12 − 18 = −6. A negative answer is fine here.

If you put 9 in place of p by mistake, you get 27 − 8 = 19. That is why the order of the two numbers matters in almost every rule. So the answer is (b) −6.

Question 3

If a @ b = a × b − a and a # b = a + 2b, what is the value of (4 @ 3) # 2?

(a) 24 (b) 18 (c) 12 (d) 10

Answer. Do the bracket first. 4 @ 3 = 4 × 3 − 4 = 12 − 4 = 8.

Now the expression is 8 # 2, so a = 8 and b = 2. That gives 8 + 2 × 2 = 8 + 4 = 12.

If you start from the right instead, you get 3 # 2 = 7 and then 4 @ 7 = 24. The bracket says 4 @ 3 comes first, so that is wrong. So the answer is (c) 12.

Question 4

If a @ b = a² + b and a # b = a × b − b, what is the value of 5 # (3 @ 2)?

(a) 50 (b) 146 (c) 44 (d) 100

Answer. The bracket comes first: 3 @ 2 = 3² + 2 = 9 + 2 = 11.

Now find 5 # 11. The bracket stood second, so 11 is b and 5 is a. 5 # 11 = 5 × 11 − 11 = 55 − 11 = 44.

Putting 11 in the a place gives 11 # 5 = 55 − 5 = 50, which is why 50 is among the options. So the answer is (c) 44.

Time check: two short rules like these should take about 40 seconds.

Finding the Rule from Examples

Often the rule is not printed. Instead you get examples and have to find the rule yourself:

"If 5 # 1 = 26 and 2 # 8 = 68, what is the value of 3 # 9?"

Here 5² + 1² = 25 + 1 = 26 and 2² + 8² = 4 + 64 = 68. So the rule is a² + b², and 3 # 9 = 9 + 81 = 90.

The usual families

Learn this small set of rules by heart. Here is what each gives for a = 8 and b = 5.

Rule For 8 and 5
a² + b² 64 + 25 = 89
a² − b² 64 − 25 = 39
(a + b)² 13² = 169
a × b + a + b 40 + 13 = 53
a × b − (a + b) 40 − 13 = 27
a + b, then a − b, written side by side 13 and 3, so 133
a × b, then a + b, written side by side 40 and 13, so 4013

Reading the size of the answer

Compare the result with a and b before you try anything.

  • A perfect square such as 36, 64 or 81 points to (a + b)². Check whether its root is a + b.
  • Close to a² + b² (add the two squares and compare). If the result is below a², try a² − b² instead.
  • Just above or below a × b. Work out a × b and see what is left over. If the leftover is a + b, the rule is a × b + a + b or a × b − (a + b).
  • Too many digits for any sum or product of small numbers, like 133 from 8 and 5, usually means two results written side by side. Split it into two parts and see whether one part is a + b and the other a − b or a × b.

Work order

  1. Guess a rule from the first example.
  2. Test it on the second example. If it fails, drop it and try the next family.
  3. Only when the rule fits every example, use it on the target.

The time target for these is 30 to 45 seconds. Knowing the families by heart is what makes that possible, because then you test, rather than search.

Solved Questions: Rules from Examples

Question 5

If 4 @ 3 = 25 and 6 @ 2 = 40, then what is the value of 5 @ 4?

(a) 81 (b) 41 (c) 20 (d) 61

Answer. Try the common rules on the first example. 4² + 3² = 16 + 9 = 25. That fits. Now test it on the second example: 6² + 2² = 36 + 4 = 40. It fits again, so the rule is a² + b².

Then 5 @ 4 = 5² + 4² = 25 + 16 = 41.

A rule such as (a + b)² fails at once, because it gives 49 for the first example, not 25. So the answer is (b) 41.

Question 6

If 4 # 2 = 12 and 7 # 3 = 40, what is the value of 6 # 5?

(a) 61 (b) 31 (c) 1 (d) 11

Answer. The results are well below a², so something is being taken away. 4² − 2² = 16 − 4 = 12. Check it on the second example: 7² − 3² = 49 − 9 = 40. Both fit, so a # b = a² − b².

The first example also fits 4 × 2 + 4 = 12. But on the second example that idea gives 7 × 3 + 7 = 28, not 40, so it is out. This is exactly why the question gives two examples.

Now 6 # 5 = 36 − 25 = 11. So the answer is (d) 11.

Question 7

If 2 & 5 = 49 and 4 & 2 = 36, what is the value of 6 & 3?

(a) 45 (b) 81 (c) 18 (d) 9

Answer. 49 and 36 are both perfect squares: 49 = 7² and 36 = 6². And 2 + 5 = 7, 4 + 2 = 6. So a & b = (a + b)².

Then 6 & 3 = (6 + 3)² = 9² = 81.

Notice that a² + b² would give 4 + 25 = 29 for the first example, not 49. So the answer is (b) 81.

Why Two Examples, and How to Check a Rule

One example is not enough

A single example usually fits more than one rule. Take 4 @ 2 = 20.

  • a² + b² gives 16 + 4 = 20.
  • a² + 2b gives 16 + 4 = 20.
  • a × b + 3a gives 8 + 12 = 20.

All three fit. That is why the question gives a second example, say 6 @ 1 = 37.

  • a² + b² gives 36 + 1 = 37. Fits.
  • a² + 2b gives 36 + 2 = 38. Fails.
  • a × b + 3a gives 6 + 18 = 24. Fails.

Only a² + b² survives both. So never settle on a rule after one example. Always test it on every example given.

The wrong options are often other rules

Setters like to fill the options with values that the "almost" rules give, the ones that fit the first example but fail the second. If your answer is one of those, you have probably stopped after one example. A rule that fits both examples is your answer.

Results written side by side

When a result looks too big, split it. 133 from 8 and 5 can be read as 13 and 3, which are 8 + 5 and 8 − 5. A four-digit result like 4013 from the same numbers is 40 and 13, which are 8 × 5 and 8 + 5.

Two things to check:

  • The order of the parts. "a + b then a − b" and "a − b then a + b" give different answers, 133 and 313 here. Read the order from the examples, not from habit.
  • Where to split. Let the examples guide you. If a + b is a two-digit number, the first part has two digits.

A last check

Once you have the target value, glance at the options. If two options look like the same digits in a different order, you have met a side-by-side rule, and the order of the parts decides between them.

Solved Questions: More Rule Families

Question 8

If 4 % 5 = 29 and 3 % 7 = 31, what is the value of 8 % 4?

(a) 32 (b) 41 (c) 44 (d) 40

Answer. The results are a little more than the products. 4 × 5 = 20, and 29 − 20 = 9, which is 4 + 5. Check it on the second example: 3 × 7 = 21, and 21 + 3 + 7 = 31. It fits, so a % b = a × b + a + b.

Now 8 % 4 = 32 + 8 + 4 = 44. Adding a fixed 9 to the product, as the first example alone suggests, gives 41. So the answer is (c) 44.

Question 9

If 4 & 6 = 14 and 5 & 7 = 23, what is the value of 8 & 3?

(a) 13 (b) 19 (c) 24 (d) 35

Answer. This time the results are less than the products. 4 × 6 = 24, and 24 − 14 = 10, which is 4 + 6. Check: 5 × 7 = 35, and 35 − (5 + 7) = 35 − 12 = 23. So a & b = a × b − (a + b).

Then 8 & 3 = 24 − (8 + 3) = 24 − 11 = 13.

Watch the bracket. If you drop it, you get 24 − 8 + 3 = 19, which is one of the options. So the answer is (a) 13.

Question 10

If 4 @ 2 = 62 and 9 @ 5 = 144, what is the value of 7 @ 4?

(a) 311 (b) 113 (c) 1128 (d) 33

Answer. 62 is not a square, and it is too big for a small sum of 4 and 2. Read it as two numbers side by side, 6 and 2. 4 + 2 = 6 and 4 − 2 = 2. Check it on the second example: 9 + 5 = 14 and 9 − 5 = 4, and written together they make 144. So the rule is a + b, then a − b next to it.

For 7 @ 4, 7 + 4 = 11 and 7 − 4 = 3, which gives 113. Writing the parts in the other order gives 311, the trap. So the answer is (b) 113.

Question 11

If 3 @ 3 = 12 and 5 @ 2 = 15, what is the value of 4 @ 6?

(a) 20 (b) 30 (c) 22 (d) 28

Answer. The first example alone fits several rules: 3 × 3 + 3 = 12, (3 + 3) × 2 = 12 and 3² + 3 = 12. Even a × b + b gives 12 here. Use the second example to choose.

  • a × b + a: 5 × 2 + 5 = 15. Fits.
  • (a + b) × 2: 7 × 2 = 14. Fails.
  • a² + b: 25 + 2 = 27. Fails.
  • a × b + b: 10 + 2 = 12. Fails.

Only a × b + a fits both, so 4 @ 6 = 24 + 4 = 28. The other options, 20, 30 and 22, are what the rejected rules give for 4 and 6. So the answer is (d) 28.

Coded Inequalities: Decode First

In this type the signs >, <, = and so on are hidden behind symbols. The question tells you what each symbol means:

'P @ Q' means 'P is greater than Q', 'P # Q' means 'P is less than Q' and 'P % Q' means 'P is equal to Q'.

Then it gives some statements and two conclusions, and asks which conclusions are true.

Step 1: decode every statement

Rewrite each coded statement with the real sign before you think about anything else. With the meanings above:

  • A @ B becomes A > B.
  • B % C becomes B = C.
  • C # D becomes C < D.

Decode the conclusions too. A conclusion "D @ B" means D > B.

Some questions also use "greater than or equal to" (≥) and "less than or equal to" (≤). Write those as ≥ and ≤. Do not round them off to > or <.

Step 2: join the statements into a chain

Join the statements where they share a letter: A > B = C < D.

It helps to make the signs point the same way wherever you can. A statement like "D # C" (D < C) is the same as C > D, so you can turn it round to fit the chain.

What a chain tells you

Walk along the chain from one letter to the other and look at the signs you pass.

Signs on the way What you can say
All point the same way, at least one is > (or <) strict: > (or <)
All point the same way, made of ≥ and = only ≥ (or ≤)
All are = =
Some point one way, some the other nothing certain

For example, in A > B = C < D, the way from A to C passes > and =, so A > C. But the way from A to D passes > and then <. The signs turn round at C, so nothing is certain about A and D.

Time

Decoding takes most of the time, so do it neatly once. A coded inequality should take 30 to 45 seconds.

Solved Questions: Coded Inequalities

Question 12

In the following question, 'P @ Q' means 'P is greater than Q', 'P # Q' means 'P is less than Q' and 'P % Q' means 'P is equal to Q'.

Statements: K @ L, L % M, M # N

Conclusions: I. K @ M II. N # L

(a) Only I is true (b) Only II is true (c) Both are true (d) Either I or II is true

Answer. Decode first. K @ L is K > L, L % M is L = M, and M # N is M < N. Put them in one line: K > L = M < N.

I. K @ M means K > M. Going from K to M, the signs are > and =, so K > M for sure. True.

II. N # L means N < L. But M < N and L = M, so N is bigger than L. II is false.

So the answer is (a) Only I is true.

Question 13

In the following question, 'P ★ Q' means 'P is greater than Q', 'P & Q' means 'P is less than Q' and 'P © Q' means 'P is equal to Q'.

Statements: R & S, S © T, T & U

Conclusions: I. U ★ R II. S & U

(a) Only I (b) Either I or II (c) Neither I nor II (d) Both I and II

Answer. The symbols are new here, so decode with care. R & S is R < S, S © T is S = T, and T & U is T < U. Joined: R < S = T < U. Every sign points the same way.

I. U ★ R means U > R. From R up to U every step goes up, so U > R. True.

II. S & U means S < U. S = T and T < U, so S < U. True.

So the answer is (d) Both I and II.

Question 14

In the following question, 'P @ Q' means 'P is greater than Q', 'P # Q' means 'P is less than Q' and 'P % Q' means 'P is equal to Q'.

Statements: B @ C, C # D, D % E

Conclusions: I. B @ D II. E @ B

(a) Only II is true (b) Neither I nor II is true (c) Either I or II is true (d) Both I and II are true

Answer. Decoded: B > C, C < D and D = E. Joined: B > C < D = E. The signs turn round at C. B and D are both bigger than C, but nothing says which of them is bigger.

I. B @ D means B > D. Not certain.

II. E @ B means E > B. Since E = D, that is the same as D > B. Not certain either.

Both conclusions are about B and D, so check the either-or case too. B could also be equal to D, and then both conclusions are false, so the pair does not cover every case. So the answer is (b) Neither I nor II is true.

Testing Conclusions, and the Either-Or Case

"True" means true in every case

A conclusion counts as true only if it must hold, whatever the actual values are. If it is true in some cases and false in others, it does not follow.

For example, F ≥ G allows F > G and also F = G. So the conclusion F > G is not certain, and neither is F = G.

A quick way to test

  • Find both letters of the conclusion in your chain.
  • Walk from one to the other and read the signs on the way.
  • If the signs all point the same way, the relation is fixed: strict if any sign on the way is strict, ≥ or ≤ if not.
  • If the signs turn round anywhere, nothing is certain.
  • Then compare with what the conclusion claims. A > B is true if the chain gives >. It is not certain if the chain only gives ≥.

The either-or case

Sometimes neither conclusion is certain on its own, yet one of the two must be true. Then the answer is "Either I or II is true". Three things must all hold:

  1. Both conclusions are about the same two letters.
  2. Neither conclusion is certain by itself.
  3. Between them they cover every case, so that exactly one is always true.

The common pairs are these.

  • The chain gives A ≥ B, and the conclusions are A > B and A = B.
  • The chain gives A ≤ B, and the conclusions are A < B and A = B.
  • The chain gives nothing about A and B, and the conclusions are A > B and A ≤ B (or A < B and A ≥ B).

The trap: > and < are not a full pair

If the conclusions are A > B and A < B, they leave out A = B. When A could equal B, both conclusions can be false together, so the answer is "Neither", not "Either". Check for the equal case before you mark Either.

Order of checking

Test I. Test II. If either one is certain, the answer is Only I, Only II or Both, and Either is out. Only when both fail do you ask whether they form an either-or pair.

[SSC Tip] Write the decoded chain once, neatly, at the top of your rough work. Most wrong answers in this type come from decoding one symbol the wrong way, not from the logic after it.

Solved Questions: Either-Or and Longer Chains

Question 15

In the following question, 'P ◆ Q' means 'P is greater than or equal to Q', 'P @ Q' means 'P is greater than Q', 'P % Q' means 'P is equal to Q' and 'P # Q' means 'P is less than Q'.

Statements: F ◆ G, G % H, H @ J

Conclusions: I. F @ H II. F % H

(a) Only I follows (b) Only II follows (c) Either I or II follows (d) Neither I nor II follows

Answer. Decoded: F ≥ G, G = H and H > J. Joined: F ≥ G = H > J. Going from F to H, the signs are ≥ and =, so F ≥ H.

I says F > H, and II says F = H. Neither is certain on its own, because F ≥ H allows both. But F ≥ H also means one of them must be true. Both are about the same pair, F and H, and together they cover every case. That is the either-or case. So the answer is (c) Either I or II follows.

Question 16

In the following question, 'P ◆ Q' means 'P is greater than or equal to Q', 'P @ Q' means 'P is greater than Q', 'P % Q' means 'P is equal to Q' and 'P # Q' means 'P is less than Q'.

Statements: V ◆ W, W @ X, Y @ X

Conclusions: I. Y @ W II. V @ X

(a) Only I is true (b) Only II is true (c) Both are true (d) Neither is true

Answer. Decoded: V ≥ W, W > X and Y > X. Joined: V ≥ W > X < Y.

I. Y @ W means Y > W. Y and W are both bigger than X, but the signs turn round at X, so nothing links Y to W. Not certain.

II. V @ X means V > X. Going from V to X the signs are ≥ and then >. One strict sign on the way is enough, so V > X for sure. True.

So the answer is (b) Only II is true.

Question 17

In the following question, 'P & Q' means 'P is less than or equal to Q', 'P # Q' means 'P is less than Q', 'P @ Q' means 'P is greater than Q' and 'P % Q' means 'P is equal to Q'.

Statements: W # X, X % Y, Z & Y

Conclusions: I. W # Z II. Z & W

(a) Only II (b) Both I and II (c) Neither I nor II (d) Either I or II

Answer. Decoded: W < X, X = Y and Z ≤ Y. So W < X = Y ≥ Z. W and Z are both on the low side of Y, and nothing compares them directly. So neither conclusion is certain.

Now look at the pair. I says W < Z. II says Z ≤ W, which is the same as W ≥ Z. For any two values, either W < Z or W ≥ Z, so exactly one of them must hold. Same pair, opposite cases, nothing left over. So the answer is (d) Either I or II.

Question 18

In the following question, 'P ◆ Q' means 'P is greater than or equal to Q', 'P & Q' means 'P is less than or equal to Q', 'P @ Q' means 'P is greater than Q', 'P # Q' means 'P is less than Q' and 'P % Q' means 'P is equal to Q'.

Statements: G ◆ H, H % J, J @ K, L & K

Conclusions: I. G @ L II. J @ L

(a) Only I follows (b) Both follow (c) Only II follows (d) Neither follows

Answer. Decoded: G ≥ H, H = J, J > K and L ≤ K. Turn the last one round so all the signs point the same way: K ≥ L. The chain is G ≥ H = J > K ≥ L.

I. G @ L means G > L. From G down to L the signs are ≥, =, > and ≥. There is one strict > on the way, so G > L. True.

II. J @ L means J > L. From J the signs are > and ≥, so J > L. True.

So the answer is (b) Both follow.

Time check: with five symbols, decoding is the slow part. Once the chain is written, each conclusion takes a few seconds.