The Charging-Capacitor Paradox

Take a parallel-plate capacitor being charged by a time-dependent current i(t)i(t), and ask for the magnetic field at a point P just outside it, near the connecting wire. Apply Ampere's circuital law, Bdl=μ0i(t)\oint\vec{B}\cdot d\vec{l} = \mu_0 i(t), to a circular loop of radius r around the wire:

  • Surface 1 — a flat disc spanning the loop, pierced by the wire: B(2πr)=μ0i(t)B(2\pi r) = \mu_0 i(t). Fine.
  • Surface 2 — a pot-shaped surface with the same circular mouth, whose bottom passes between the capacitor plates, touching no wire: enclosed current zero, so the law says B(2πr)=0B(2\pi r) = 0.
  • A tiffin-box-shaped surface does the same.

Contradiction! The same point P has a field computed one way and zero computed another. Since Ampere's law produced it, Ampere's law must be incomplete — something must be added so that every surface with the same boundary gives the same answer.

Charging capacitor with flat and pot shaped Amperian surfaces and displacement current

Maxwell's Fix: The Displacement Current

Look at what does cross the gap-spanning surface: the electric field! Between plates of area A carrying charge Q, E=QAε0E = \frac{Q}{A\varepsilon_0} (perpendicular to the surface), so the electric flux is

ΦE=EA=Qε0\Phi_E = EA = \frac{Q}{\varepsilon_0}

As the capacitor charges, Q changes, and

ε0dΦEdt=dQdt=i\varepsilon_0\frac{d\Phi_E}{dt} = \frac{dQ}{dt} = i

exactly the missing current! Maxwell's resolution: a changing electric flux acts as a current, the displacement current

id=ε0dΦEdt\boxed{i_d = \varepsilon_0\frac{d\Phi_E}{dt}}

The total current is i=ic+idi = i_c + i_d (conduction + displacement), and the Ampere-Maxwell law reads

Bdl=μ0ic+μ0ε0dΦEdt\boxed{\oint\vec{B}\cdot d\vec{l} = \mu_0 i_c + \mu_0\varepsilon_0\frac{d\Phi_E}{dt}}

Bookkeeping for the capacitor: outside (in the wire) ic=ii_c = i, id=0i_d = 0; inside the gap ic=0i_c = 0, id=ii_d = i. Every surface now reports the same total current — paradox dissolved.

Key Point: idi_d has all the physical effects of a real current — it produces magnetic fields. The field at a point M between the plates is measurably the same as at P just outside.

Consequences: A More Symmetric Electromagnetism

With the displacement current in place:

  • Faraday's law: a time-varying magnetic field gives rise to an electric field.
  • Ampere-Maxwell law: a time-varying electric field gives rise to a magnetic field.

Time-dependent electric and magnetic fields give rise to each other — the seed of electromagnetic waves (Section 3 onwards).

NCERT's careful footnote: the symmetry is still not perfect — there are no known magnetic monopoles (no magnetic analogue of charge as a source), which is why Gauss's law for magnetism keeps its zero.

[JEE Tip] For a parallel-plate capacitor, id=ε0AdEdt=CdVdti_d = \varepsilon_0 A\frac{dE}{dt} = C\frac{dV}{dt} — three interchangeable forms (ΦE\Phi_E, E, or V version). Choose whichever the data offers.

[NEET Important] In a region with steady fields (e.g. a steady current in a wire), id=0i_d = 0: displacement current exists only while the electric field is changing. And in general both ici_c and idi_d can coexist in the same region — no medium is perfectly conducting or perfectly insulating.

Solved Examples

Example 1: Displacement current equals conduction current [NEET Numerical]

A capacitor is charged by a steady conduction current of 0.15 A in its leads. What is the displacement current between its plates?

Solution:

  1. Between the plates, the changing Q gives id=ε0dΦE/dt=dQ/dti_d = \varepsilon_0\,d\Phi_E/dt = dQ/dt.
  2. dQ/dtdQ/dt is precisely the charging current: id=0.15i_d = 0.15 A.
  3. Continuity restored: the 'current' is 0.15 A everywhere around the circuit — conduction in the wires, displacement in the gap.

Example 2: From dV/dt [JEE Numerical]

A 1.0 μ\muF parallel-plate capacitor has its potential difference rising at 5×1055 \times 10^5 V/s. Find the displacement current.

Solution:

  1. id=CdVdti_d = C\frac{dV}{dt} (capacitor form of ε0dΦE/dt\varepsilon_0\,d\Phi_E/dt).
  2. id=106×5×105=0.5i_d = 10^{-6} \times 5 \times 10^5 = 0.5 A.
  3. Half an ampere flows 'through' the gap — as a changing field, not as charge.

Example 3: From dE/dt [JEE Numerical]

The electric field between circular plates of area 0.010.01 m2^2 changes at 101210^{12} V m1^{-1} s1^{-1}. Find idi_d.

Solution:

  1. id=ε0AdEdt=8.85×1012×0.01×1012i_d = \varepsilon_0 A\frac{dE}{dt} = 8.85 \times 10^{-12} \times 0.01 \times 10^{12}.
  2. id=8.85×102i_d = 8.85 \times 10^{-2} A 88.5\approx 88.5 mA.
  3. Enormous dE/dt values are needed for modest currents — ε0\varepsilon_0 is tiny.

Example 4: The two-surface check

State the paradox the displacement current resolves, in two sentences.

Solution:

  1. For the same Amperian loop near a charging capacitor, a flat surface (pierced by the wire) gives B(2πr)=μ0iB(2\pi r) = \mu_0 i, while a pot-shaped surface through the gap gives zero — Ampere's law contradicts itself.
  2. Adding id=ε0dΦE/dti_d = \varepsilon_0\,d\Phi_E/dt (which lives exactly where the wire doesn't) makes the total current through every spanning surface identical.

Example 5: B between the plates [JEE Numerical]

Circular capacitor plates of radius R = 6.0 cm carry a displacement current of amplitude 6.9 μ\muA (uniformly distributed). Find the amplitude of B at r = 3.0 cm from the axis.

Solution:

  1. Inside the gap, Ampere-Maxwell on a circle of radius r encloses the fraction r2/R2r^2/R^2 of idi_d: B(2πr)=μ0idr2R2B(2\pi r) = \mu_0 i_d\frac{r^2}{R^2}.
  2. B=μ0idr2πR2=4π×107×6.9×106×0.032π×(0.06)2B = \frac{\mu_0 i_d r}{2\pi R^2} = \frac{4\pi \times 10^{-7} \times 6.9 \times 10^{-6} \times 0.03}{2\pi \times (0.06)^2}.
  3. B=2×107×6.9×106×0.033.6×1031.15×1011B = \frac{2 \times 10^{-7} \times 6.9 \times 10^{-6} \times 0.03}{3.6 \times 10^{-3}} \approx 1.15 \times 10^{-11} T.
  4. Tiny but real — and measurable, confirming the displacement current's physical reality.

Example 6: An oscillating capacitor [JEE Numerical]

A 100 pF capacitor is connected to a source V=230sin(300t)V = 230\sin(300\,t) V. Find the peak displacement current.

Solution:

  1. id=CdVdt=C×230×300cos(300t)i_d = C\frac{dV}{dt} = C \times 230 \times 300\cos(300t).
  2. Peak: idmax=100×1012×230×300=6.9×106i_d^{max} = 100 \times 10^{-12} \times 230 \times 300 = 6.9 \times 10^{-6} A.
  3. The 6.9 μ\muA of Example 5 — these two examples are one circuit.

Example 7: Where is each current?

For the charging capacitor, fill in: in the connecting wires, ic=?i_c = ?, id=?i_d = ?; between the plates, ic=?i_c = ?, id=?i_d = ?.

Solution:

  1. Wires: ic=ii_c = i (real charge flow), id=0i_d = 0 (steady E inside a good conductor changes negligibly).
  2. Gap: ic=0i_c = 0 (no charge crosses), id=ii_d = i (the changing E carries the baton).
  3. Their sum ic+id=ii_c + i_d = i is the same through every cross-section — current continuity, rescued.

Example 8: When is idi_d zero?

Give a situation with a non-zero electric field but zero displacement current, and one with id0i_d \ne 0 in empty space.

Solution:

  1. Zero idi_d: a steady electric field (e.g. inside a wire carrying steady DC, or a fully charged capacitor) — E exists but dE/dt=0dE/dt = 0.
  2. Non-zero idi_d in vacuum: any region where E varies with time — e.g. between charging plates, or in a passing electromagnetic wave — produces a magnetic field with no conduction current anywhere nearby.
  3. That second case is precisely how EM waves sustain themselves.

Example 9: The symmetry argument

In what sense does the displacement current make electromagnetism 'more symmetrical' — and why not perfectly so?

Solution:

  1. Faraday: changing B \to E. Ampere-Maxwell: changing E \to B. Each field now sources the other — a beautiful reciprocity.
  2. The symmetry is imperfect because magnetic monopoles do not exist: electric fields have point sources (charges); magnetic fields do not.
  3. Hence Gauss's law for E has Q/ε0Q/\varepsilon_0 on the right; Gauss's law for B has zero.

Example 10: Reading the Ampere-Maxwell law

Identify each term of Bdl=μ0ic+μ0ε0dΦE/dt\oint\vec{B}\cdot d\vec{l} = \mu_0 i_c + \mu_0\varepsilon_0\,d\Phi_E/dt and when each dominates.

Solution:

  1. Left side: circulation of B around a closed loop.
  2. μ0ic\mu_0 i_c: conduction-current source — dominates in wires and circuits.
  3. μ0ε0dΦE/dt\mu_0\varepsilon_0\,d\Phi_E/dt: displacement-current source — the only term in charging-capacitor gaps and in electromagnetic waves; both can coexist in ordinary (imperfect) media.