How Coordination Compounds Is Asked

This chapter carries 11 printed marks: usually two 1-mark questions and three of the five group IV questions in Part C. Prepare it well and it can cover the whole of group IV on its own.

What to prepare, based on the last ten papers:

Where Asked more than once Also asked
Part A (1 mark) Linkage isomerism (3 times); homoleptic complexes, oxidation state of Ni in Ni(CO)4_4 (twice each) Shape of Fe(CO)5_5, Werner's valencies from AgCl data, inner and outer orbital complexes, Δt\Delta_t and Δo\Delta_o, ambidentate and polydentate ligands
Part C (3 marks) A VBT question in 8 of 10 papers ([Ni(CN)4_4]2−^{2-} 4 times, [Co(NH3_3)6_6]3+^{3+} twice); Werner's postulates, Co2_2(CO)8_8, CFT splitting diagram (3 times each); Mn2_2(CO)10_{10}, cis and trans [MX2_2(L–L)2_2], fac and mer isomers, Werner's AgCl experiments (twice each) [CoF6_6]3−^{3-}, [NiCl4_4]2−^{2-}, bonding in metal carbonyls, complexes of en, limitations of VBT

Werner's Theory and Basic Terms

Werner's postulates:

  1. The metal in a coordination compound shows two kinds of valency: primary and secondary.
  2. Primary valencies are ionisable and are satisfied by negative ions. They correspond to the oxidation state.
  3. Secondary valencies are non-ionisable and are satisfied by neutral molecules or negative ions. Their number equals the coordination number, and it is fixed for a metal.
  4. Secondary valencies point in fixed directions in space, which gives the complex its shape.

AgNO3_3 test: only the chloride ions outside the square bracket (primary valency) are precipitated as AgCl.

Formula as written Moles of AgCl Complex
CoCl3_3·6NH3_3 3 [Co(NH3_3)6_6]Cl3_3
CoCl3_3·5NH3_3 2 [Co(NH3_3)5_5Cl]Cl2_2
CoCl3_3·4NH3_3 1 [Co(NH3_3)4_4Cl2_2]Cl (green trans and violet cis forms)

Key terms:

  • Ligand: an ion or molecule that donates a lone pair to the central metal.
  • Denticity: unidentate (Cl−^-, NH3_3, H2_2O), didentate (en, C2_2O42−_4^{2-}), polydentate (EDTA4−^{4-} is hexadentate).
  • Ambidentate ligand: can bind through two different atoms, for example NO2−_2^- (N or O) and SCN−^- (S or N).
  • Chelate: a ring formed when a di- or polydentate ligand binds through two or more atoms. Chelates are more stable, so oxalate gives more stable complexes than Cl−^-, and [Fe(C2_2O4_4)3_3]3−^{3-} is more stable than [Fe(H2_2O)6_6]3+^{3+}.
  • Homoleptic: only one kind of ligand, like [Co(NH3_3)6_6]Cl3_3. Heteroleptic: more than one kind, like [Co(NH3_3)4_4Cl2_2]+^+.

Complexes in daily life: haemoglobin (Fe), chlorophyll (Mg), vitamin B12_{12} (Co), Wilkinson's catalyst (Ph3_3P)3_3RhCl, EDTA for estimating hardness of water, cis-platin against cancer.

Naming Complexes

Name the cation first, then the anion. Inside the bracket: ligands in alphabetical order (prefixes like di-, tri- don't count), then the metal, then its oxidation state in Roman numerals. An anionic complex ends in -ate.

Complex Name
[Co(NH3_3)6_6]Cl3_3 hexaamminecobalt(III) chloride
[Co(NH3_3)5_5Br]SO4_4 pentaamminebromidocobalt(III) sulphate
[CoCl2_2(en)2_2]+^+ dichloridobis(ethane-1,2-diamine)cobalt(III) ion
[Fe(en)2_2Cl2_2]Cl dichloridobis(ethane-1,2-diamine)iron(III) chloride
K3_3[Fe(C2_2O4_4)3_3] potassium trioxalatoferrate(III)
[Ni(CO)4_4] tetracarbonylnickel(0)
[Fe(CO)5_5] pentacarbonyliron(0)
[Co2_2(CO)8_8] octacarbonyldicobalt(0)
[Mn2_2(CO)10_{10}] decacarbonyldimanganese(0)

To find the oxidation state, set the sum of charges equal to the charge on the complex. In [Fe(C2_2O4_4)3_3]3−^{3-}: x+3(−2)=−3x + 3(-2) = -3, so x=+3x = +3, and three didentate ligands make the coordination number 6. In [Ni(CO)4_4], CO is neutral, so Ni is 0.

Isomerism

Type What changes Example
Linkage (structural) Which atom of an ambidentate ligand binds [Co(NH3_3)5_5(ONO)]Cl2_2 (red, through O) and [Co(NH3_3)5_5(NO2_2)]Cl2_2 (yellow, through N)
Coordination (structural) Ligands swap between cation and anion complexes [Co(NH3_3)6_6][Cr(CN)6_6] and [Cr(NH3_3)6_6][Co(CN)6_6]
Ionisation (structural) An ion swaps between inside and outside the bracket [Co(NH3_3)5_5SO4_4]Br and [Co(NH3_3)5_5Br]SO4_4
Solvate (structural) Water inside or outside the bracket [Cr(H2_2O)6_6]Cl3_3 and [Cr(H2_2O)5_5Cl]Cl2_2·H2_2O
Geometrical (stereo) Arrangement in space cis and trans; fac and mer
Optical (stereo) Non-superimposable mirror images [Co(en)3_3]3+^{3+}

Geometrical isomerism is stereoisomerism, not structural.

Geometrical isomers you must be able to draw:

  • [MA4_4B2_2] or [Co(NH3_3)4_4Cl2_2]+^+ (octahedral): cis (two Cl at 90°) and trans (two Cl opposite each other).
  • [MA3_3B3_3], such as Co(NH3_3)3_3(NO2_2)3_3: fac, with the three identical ligands on one face, and mer, with them around a meridian. Coordination number 6, all ligands unidentate.
  • [MX2_2(L–L)2_2], such as [CoCl2_2(en)2_2]+^+ or [PtCl2_2(en)2_2]2+^{2+}: the cis form has no plane of symmetry, so it is optically active (chiral, two enantiomers). The trans form has a mirror plane, so it is optically inactive.

Cis and trans geometric isomers in square planar and octahedral complexes

Valence Bond Theory

Steps for any VBT answer: write the metal ion's configuration, decide whether the ligand forces pairing (strong field: CN−^-, CO, NH3_3 with Co3+^{3+}, en) or not (weak field: F−^-, Cl−^-, H2_2O), then pick the hybridisation, shape and magnetism.

Complex Metal ion Ligand field Hybridisation Shape Unpaired e−^- Magnetism
[Co(NH3_3)6_6]3+^{3+} Co3+^{3+}, 3d6^6 strong, pairs d2^2sp3^3 (inner orbital) octahedral 0 diamagnetic
[CoF6_6]3−^{3-} Co3+^{3+}, 3d6^6 weak, no pairing sp3^3d2^2 (outer orbital) octahedral 4 paramagnetic
[Ni(CN)4_4]2−^{2-} Ni2+^{2+}, 3d8^8 strong, pairs dsp2^2 square planar 0 diamagnetic
[NiCl4_4]2−^{2-} Ni2+^{2+}, 3d8^8 weak, no pairing sp3^3 tetrahedral 2 paramagnetic
[Ni(CO)4_4] Ni(0), 3d10^{10} after 4s electrons pair into 3d – sp3^3 tetrahedral 0 diamagnetic
[Mn(CN)6_6]3−^{3-} Mn3+^{3+}, 3d4^4 strong d2^2sp3^3 (inner orbital) octahedral 2 paramagnetic
[FeF6_6]3−^{3-} Fe3+^{3+}, 3d5^5 weak sp3^3d2^2 (outer orbital) octahedral 5 paramagnetic

Limitations of VBT: it rests on several assumptions; it doesn't explain magnetic data quantitatively; it doesn't explain the colour of complexes; it gives no quantitative idea of stability; it can't predict whether a 4-coordinate complex will be tetrahedral or square planar; and it doesn't separate weak and strong ligands.

Crystal Field Theory and Metal Carbonyls

Octahedral splitting: six ligands approaching along the axes push up the two orbitals that point at them. The five d orbitals split into a higher eg_g set (dx2−y2_{x^2-y^2}, dz2_{z^2}), raised by 0.6Δo\Delta_o, and a lower t2g_{2g} set (dxy_{xy}, dyz_{yz}, dxz_{xz}), lowered by 0.4Δo\Delta_o. In a tetrahedral field the order is reversed and the gap is smaller: Δt=49Δo\Delta_t = \frac{4}{9}\Delta_o.

Crystal field splitting of d orbitals in octahedral and tetrahedral fields

For d4^4: the fourth electron either pairs up in t2g_{2g} or goes up to eg_g, depending on which costs less energy.

  • If Δo<P\Delta_o < P (weak field): t2g3_{2g}^3 eg1_g^1, high spin.
  • If Δo>P\Delta_o > P (strong field): t2g4_{2g}^4 eg0_g^0, low spin.

Spectrochemical series (weak to strong): I−^- < Br−^- < SCN−^- < Cl−^- < S2−^{2-} < F−^- < OH−^- < C2_2O42−_4^{2-} < H2_2O < NCS−^- < EDTA4−^{4-} < NH3_3 < en < CN−^- < CO

Splitting also grows with the charge on the metal and from tetrahedral to octahedral. So the increasing order of splitting is [NiCl4_4]2−^{2-} < [CoF6_6]3−^{3-} < [Co(H2_2O)6_6]3+^{3+} < [Co(CN)6_6]3−^{3-}.

Colour: an electron jumps from t2g_{2g} to eg_g by absorbing visible light, and we see the complementary colour. [Ti(H2_2O)6_6]3+^{3+} is violet for this reason.

Metal carbonyls:

Carbonyl Shape
[Ni(CO)4_4] tetrahedral
[Fe(CO)5_5] trigonal bipyramidal
[Cr(CO)6_6] octahedral
[Mn2_2(CO)10_{10}] two square pyramidal Mn(CO)5_5 units joined by an Mn–Mn bond
[Co2_2(CO)8_8] Co–Co bond with two bridging CO groups

Bonding: the M–C σ bond forms when the lone pair on the carbon of CO is donated into an empty metal orbital. The M–C π bond forms when a filled metal d orbital gives electrons back into the empty antibonding π* orbital of CO. Each strengthens the other, so the bonding is called synergic.

Solved Examples: Werner's Theory and Naming

Question 1 (3 marks): State three postulates of Werner's theory.

Answer. The postulates of Werner's theory of coordination compounds are:

  1. In coordination compounds, the metal shows two types of valencies: primary valency and secondary valency.
  2. Primary valencies are ionisable and are satisfied by negative ions. They correspond to the oxidation state of the metal.
  3. Secondary valencies are non-ionisable and are satisfied by neutral molecules or negative ions. The secondary valency is equal to the coordination number, and these valencies are directed in space, which gives the complex its definite shape.

Question 2 (3 marks): CoCl3_3·6NH3_3 gives 3 moles of AgCl with excess AgNO3_3. Write its formula as a complex, its primary and secondary valencies, and its IUPAC name.

Answer. Since 3 moles of AgCl are formed, all three chloride ions are outside the coordination sphere.

Formula of the complex: [Co(NH3_3)6_6]Cl3_3

Primary valency = 3 (the oxidation state of cobalt is +3). Secondary valency = 6 (six NH3_3 ligands).

IUPAC name: hexaamminecobalt(III) chloride

Question 3 (3 marks): CoCl3_3·4NH3_3 gives 1 mole of AgCl with excess AgNO3_3. Write the formula of the complex and draw its geometrical isomers.

Answer. Since only 1 mole of AgCl is formed, only one Cl−^- is outside the coordination sphere. The formula of the complex is [Co(NH3_3)4_4Cl2_2]Cl.

The complex is octahedral and shows two geometrical isomers:

  • cis isomer: the two Cl ligands are on adjacent positions, at 90° to each other (violet).
  • trans isomer: the two Cl ligands are on opposite positions, at 180° to each other (green).

Draw two octahedra: one with the two Cl next to each other (cis) and one with the two Cl opposite each other (trans), with NH3_3 at the other four positions.

cis and trans isomers of Pt(NH3)2Cl2 and Co(NH3)4Cl2

Question 4 (3 marks): For [Fe(en)2_2Cl2_2]Cl: (a) what is the oxidation state of Fe? (b) What is the coordination number? (c) How many moles of AgNO3_3 react with one mole of the complex?

Answer.

(a) Let the oxidation state of Fe be x. en is neutral and each Cl is −1, and the complex ion has a charge of +1.

x+2(0)+2(−1)=+1x + 2(0) + 2(-1) = +1, so x=+3x = +3. The oxidation state of Fe is +3.

(b) en is a didentate ligand. Two en and two Cl give 2 × 2 + 2 = 6. The coordination number of Fe is 6.

(c) Only the one Cl−^- outside the bracket is ionisable, so 1 mole of AgNO3_3 reacts with one mole of the complex.

Solved Examples: VBT and CFT

Question 5 (3 marks): Using VBT, explain the hybridisation, geometry and magnetic property of [Ni(CN)4_4]2−^{2-}. (Atomic number of Ni = 28)

Answer. In [Ni(CN)4_4]2−^{2-}, nickel is in the +2 state. Ni is [Ar] 3d8^8 4s2^2, so Ni2+^{2+} is [Ar] 3d8^8 with two unpaired electrons.

CN−^- is a strong field ligand. It forces the two unpaired 3d electrons to pair up, leaving one 3d orbital empty. One 3d, one 4s and two 4p orbitals mix to form four dsp2^2 hybrid orbitals, which accept four electron pairs from four CN−^- ions.

3d 4s 4p
Ni2+^{2+} ion ↑↓ ↑↓ ↑↓ ↑ ↑ [ ] [ ] [ ] [ ]
In [Ni(CN)4_4]2−^{2-} ↑↓ ↑↓ ↑↓ ↑↓ xx xx xx xx [ ]

(xx = electron pair donated by CN−^-)

  • Hybridisation: dsp2^2
  • Geometry: square planar
  • Magnetic property: no unpaired electrons, so it is diamagnetic

Question 6 (3 marks): Using VBT, explain the hybridisation, geometry and magnetic property of [CoF6_6]3−^{3-}. (Atomic number of Co = 27)

Answer. In [CoF6_6]3−^{3-}, cobalt is in the +3 state. Co is [Ar] 3d7^7 4s2^2, so Co3+^{3+} is [Ar] 3d6^6 with four unpaired electrons.

F−^- is a weak field ligand, so the 3d electrons do not pair up. One 4s, three 4p and two 4d orbitals mix to form six sp3^3d2^2 hybrid orbitals, which accept six electron pairs from six F−^- ions.

3d 4s 4p 4d
Co3+^{3+} ion ↑↓ ↑ ↑ ↑ ↑ [ ] [ ] [ ] [ ] [ ] [ ] [ ] [ ] [ ]
In [CoF6_6]3−^{3-} ↑↓ ↑ ↑ ↑ ↑ xx xx xx xx xx xx [ ] [ ] [ ]

(xx = electron pair donated by F−^-)

  • Hybridisation: sp3^3d2^2 (outer orbital, high spin complex)
  • Geometry: octahedral
  • Magnetic property: four unpaired electrons, so it is paramagnetic

Question 7 (3 marks): Using VBT, explain the hybridisation, geometry and magnetic property of [NiCl4_4]2−^{2-}.

Answer. In [NiCl4_4]2−^{2-}, nickel is in the +2 state, so Ni2+^{2+} is [Ar] 3d8^8 with two unpaired electrons.

Cl−^- is a weak field ligand, so the 3d electrons do not pair up. One 4s and three 4p orbitals mix to form four sp3^3 hybrid orbitals, which accept four electron pairs from four Cl−^- ions.

3d 4s 4p
Ni2+^{2+} ion ↑↓ ↑↓ ↑↓ ↑ ↑ [ ] [ ] [ ] [ ]
In [NiCl4_4]2−^{2-} ↑↓ ↑↓ ↑↓ ↑ ↑ xx xx xx xx

(xx = electron pair donated by Cl−^-)

  • Hybridisation: sp3^3
  • Geometry: tetrahedral
  • Magnetic property: two unpaired electrons, so it is paramagnetic

Question 8 (3 marks): Draw the energy level diagram for the splitting of d orbitals in an octahedral field. Write the configuration of a d4^4 ion when P>ΔoP > \Delta_o.

Answer. In an octahedral field, the five degenerate d orbitals of the free metal ion split into two sets:

  • a lower set of three orbitals, t2g_{2g} (dxy_{xy}, dyz_{yz}, dxz_{xz}), at −0.4Δo\Delta_o
  • a higher set of two orbitals, eg_g (dx2−y2_{x^2-y^2}, dz2_{z^2}), at +0.6Δo\Delta_o

Diagram: draw the five d orbitals at one level, then show them splitting into the t2g_{2g} set below and the eg_g set above. Label the energy gap as Δo\Delta_o.

When P>ΔoP > \Delta_o, the fourth electron goes into the eg_g level instead of pairing up. So the configuration of the d4^4 ion is t2g3_{2g}^3 eg1_g^1 (high spin complex).

Octahedral d4 high spin configuration

Question 9 (3 marks): Write three limitations of valence bond theory.

Answer. The limitations of valence bond theory are:

  1. It does not explain the colour of coordination compounds.
  2. It does not give a quantitative explanation of the magnetic data.
  3. It cannot exactly predict whether a 4-coordinate complex will be tetrahedral or square planar.

Solved Examples: Isomers and Carbonyls

Question 10 (3 marks): Write the geometrical isomers of [MX2_2(L–L)2_2], where X is unidentate and L–L is didentate. Which one is optically inactive?

Answer. The complex [MX2_2(L–L)2_2] is octahedral and shows two geometrical isomers:

  • cis isomer: the two X ligands are on adjacent positions.
  • trans isomer: the two X ligands are on opposite positions.

The trans isomer is optically inactive, because it has a plane of symmetry. The cis isomer has no plane of symmetry, so it exists as two optically active forms (d and l) that are mirror images of each other.

cis and trans isomers of an MX2(L-L)2 complex

Question 11 (3 marks): A complex [MA3_3B3_3] (M is +3) shows geometrical isomerism. Predict the denticity of A and B and describe the two isomers.

Answer. Both A and B are unidentate ligands. The coordination number is 6, so the complex is octahedral.

It shows two geometrical isomers:

  • Facial (fac) isomer: the three A ligands (and the three B ligands) occupy the corners of one triangular face of the octahedron.
  • Meridional (mer) isomer: the three A ligands (and the three B ligands) lie around a meridian of the octahedron.

Example: [Co(NH3_3)3_3(NO2_2)3_3].

Facial and meridional MA3B3 isomers

Question 12 (3 marks): Write the IUPAC name of [Co(NH3_3)5_5Br]SO4_4 and show the splitting of d orbitals of the metal ion according to CFT.

Answer. IUPAC name: pentaamminebromidocobalt(III) sulphate

Cobalt is in the +3 state, so Co3+^{3+} is 3d6^6. In this octahedral complex, the d orbitals split into a lower t2g_{2g} set and a higher eg_g set. NH3_3 is a strong field ligand, so all six electrons pair up in the t2g_{2g} level.

Configuration: t2g6_{2g}^6 eg0_g^0. There are no unpaired electrons, so the complex is diamagnetic.

d6 splitting in strong and weak octahedral fields

Question 13 (3 marks): Write the IUPAC name and structure of [Co2_2(CO)8_8]. How many bridging CO groups does it have?

Answer. IUPAC name: octacarbonyldicobalt(0)

Structure: the two cobalt atoms are joined by a Co–Co bond and by two bridging CO groups. Each cobalt atom also carries three terminal CO groups, so the total is 2 + 2 × 3 = 8 CO groups.

Structure of Co2(CO)8 with two bridging CO groups

Question 14 (3 marks): How many square pyramidal units are present in decacarbonyldimanganese(0)? Write its molecular formula and describe its structure.

Answer. Molecular formula: [Mn2_2(CO)10_{10}]

It has two square pyramidal Mn(CO)5_5 units. The two units are joined by an Mn–Mn bond, and there are no bridging CO groups.

Structure of Mn2(CO)10, two square pyramidal units

Question 15 (3 marks): Explain the M–C σ bond and M–C π bond in metal carbonyls.

Answer. The metal–carbon bond in metal carbonyls has both σ and π character.

  • M–C σ bond: it is formed by the donation of the lone pair of electrons on the carbon of CO into a vacant orbital of the metal.
  • M–C π bond: it is formed by the donation of a pair of electrons from a filled d orbital of the metal into the vacant antibonding π* orbital of CO.

The two bonds strengthen each other, which makes the metal–carbon bond strong. This is called synergic bonding.